7-Year-Old Suspended For Making a ‘Gun’ Out of His Breakfast

A second grader was suspended from school last Thursday because he bit his breakfast pastry into a shape that his teacher thought looked like a gun.

Yes, it’s yet another ridiculous over-reaction to a non-threat.

Seven-year-old Josh Welch, who attends Park Elementary School in Baltimore, said he was trying to nibble his strawberry snack into a mountain.

Josh, who suffers from attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and enjoys art classes, told Fox 45 that his actions were innocent.

‘It was already a rectangle and I just kept on biting it and biting it and tore off the top and it kinda looked like a gun but it wasn’t.

All I was trying to do was turn it into a mountain but, it didn’t look like a mountain really and it turned out to be a gun kinda,’ the seven-year-old recalled.

But when his teacher saw what he had done, the boy says she got ‘pretty mad’ and he knew he was ‘in big trouble.’

Zero Tolerance For Guns Out Of Control

This is not the first time in recent months that zero tolerance with respect to guns has gone out of control.

Earlier this year, Melody Valentin, a Philadelphia fifth-grader, was searched by school administrators after she allegedly threw out a piece of paper in the shape of a gun.

And in yet another egregious example, a five-year-old was suspended from Mount Carmel Area Elementary School in Mount Carmel, Pennsylvania, because she was playing with her Hello Kitty bubble gun and allegedly threatening to shoot herself and a classmate.

These are wonderful “teachable moments,” but instead of making the most of them, administrators chose to punish their students.

Suspended For Two Days

In Josh’s case, his dad received a phone call from the school saying that Josh has been suspended for two days because of what he had done. He was amazed and angry.

As Fox 45 reports:

Josh’s dad is not happy saying, “I would almost call it insanity. I mean with all the potential issues that could be dealt with at school, real threats, bullies, whatever the real issue is, it’s a pastry.., Ya know?” Josh just wishes he could go back to class, but maintains a good sense of humor through the whole debacle saying, “I didn’t get to eat all my breakfast, so, really I am still hungry.”

Well, at least Josh has a sense of humor.

If his teacher thought the 7-year-old’s action was inappropriate, couldn’t she find a better way to let him know? Teachers are supposed to understand their young charges and know how to respond to them. How about disciplining this teacher instead?

And as Josh’s father points out, schools have plenty of issues that they should be handling, without wasting time on the shape of a strawberry pastry.

School Districts Revising Zero Tolerance Policies

Thankfully some school districts around the country are recognizing that.

After the Columbine High School shootings in 1999, schools nationwide established zero tolerance weapons policies: schools had to suspend or expel students, no matter the circumstances, when weapons were involved.

Obviously this was done with the best of intentions, but there have been plenty of unintended consequences.

Last year, Colorado State Senator Linda Newell sponsored a bill which became law that permits schools to develop other options other than a mandatory suspension or expulsion after a student violates weapons policies.

Schools in Colorado now are required to develop new discipline rules, including changes to their weapons policies, to their drug and alcohol policies, and in how they handle habitually disruptive behavior.

Let’s hope word gets out to other school districts. It’s time to stop this madness.


Care2 Related Coverage

High School Student Suspended For Expressing Herself About Shootings

Seventh Grader Suspended For Touching Pill

Teacher Called Scrooge For Saying Santa Isn’t Real


Photo Credit: screenshot from Fox 45 video


Judith Emerson
Judith Emerson5 years ago

A billion-dollar daily shot in the arm for the American economy (ExxonMobil Perspectives Blog)


Joel Hunt
Joel Hunt5 years ago

Glad I'm not growing up in the current US educational system. I went through quite a long phase of loving anything 'army', and spent a lot of free time doodling soldiers and guns and battles. As I grew a bit older and got into Fantasy fiction, it turned into medieval style battles, and I was drawing swords and knights and dragons ripping people apart.

Now I'm a vegetarian pacifist who supports strict gun control.

What children enjoy playing or drawing doesn't indicate how they will act. Besides, it must be confusing growing up in a country where you have to give complete respect to soldiers, but you get punished for trying to act like one, or for making images that look like what soldiers use.

Del Rykert
Del Rykert5 years ago

A far more apprapo response from the teacher would be to ask what are you making and why did you chose to make that to see if there was a deeper need for further calm and quiet 1 on 1 discussion. To blow it so far out of balance shows how silly some alarmists feel the need to go to such ridiculous extremes. The teacher should get a suspension without pay for at least a week for over reacting. If the school board and principal supported and approved it then it is a much bigger problem that needs some serious state wide review for how teachers need to stay level headed and use common sense before going balisitic.

Ruth R.
Ruth R5 years ago

No suspension needed -- of course -- and no blame.
Get on with good living and enjoying life, and enjoying the process of learning how to learn, and learning!

Ruth R.
Ruth R5 years ago

The question is why are teachers over-reacting and what can be done to help create supportive groups for teachers?
What can make the school be and feel safe for all the teachers, workers, students -- so there can be goodness, kindness, creativitiy, fun-loving play and learning, the joy of life, the enjoyment of learning.

vicky t.
vicky T5 years ago

This is ridiculous, I feel like crying, or laughing, I don't know!
Do they realize that making something taboo will make kids crave it even more?! What The Hell!!! Children are smart, you can't just punish them for something that silly, they'll rebel!

Colin Wright
Past Member 5 years ago

This kid should be shot.

With a pastry.

Sarah S.
Sally S5 years ago

This is nuts. Surely the boy was doing exactly what education is suppose to nurture - using his imagination and thinking creatively. I appreciate that guns are a sensitive issue right now but surely a little common sense is in order too?!

Del Rykert
Del Rykert5 years ago

Terry V. ~~~ I sure agree with your post but what I find even more amazing that some were even voting that Josh should have been suspended... Have some become so desperate on gun issues that they have stopped using common sense now?

Terry V.
Terry V5 years ago

What a ridiculous article to post.