841 Goats, Some Lame and Starving, Found in Santa Cruz Barn

It might seem difficult, if not impossible, to imagine that anyone could keep 841 goats without authorities noticing. But Santa Cruz Biotechnology, a major supplier of antibodies and other materials used by molecular biology labs worldwide, was able to do just that for at least two and a half years.

“That’s virtually unheard of in my career,” Cathy Liss, president of the Animal Welfare Institute, who has been working for them since 1982, tells Nature. A December 2012 report by USDA inspectors says that the company had routinely denied the existence of the facility, which was located about 14 kilometers south of the company’s main operations in Santa Cruz.

Nature describes Santa Cruz Biotechnology “as the second-largest supplier in the U.S. $1.6-billion global market for research antibodies. While research labs never actually see the goats, the animals’ antibodies play a ‘key role in modern bioscience,’” as John Timmer explains on Ars Technica:

Antibodies are useful for several procedures conducted by biologists because they can stick so specifically to a single target. If you can raise antibodies against a specific protein, you can then use those antibodies to purify that protein out of the huge mix of proteins produced by a cell.

Goats are seen as good sources since they can generate more antibodies and have a longer lifespan than mice (which most research institutions are more familiar with). Larger blood samples can also be taken from goats. As neuroscientist Erik Ullian at the University of California, San Francisco, says, Santa Cruz Biotechnology develops more hard-to-find antibodies than other companies and sometimes is the “only option that we have for trying an antibody.”

Under the Animal Welfare Act, animals with conditions that cause them pain are to be euthanized. The USDA had cited Santa Cruz Biotechnology for violating animal welfare laws a number of times in the past as far back as 2005, when it had to pay $4,600 in fines resulting from violations in “animal sanitation, veterinary care, and training.” Investigators found flies around the animals’ enclosures and the use of “unacceptable forms of euthanasia, as well as using more than 1,000 rabbits when a protocol authorized the use of 80.”

A USDA inspection on on May 5, 2010, found instances of “lame animals, incomplete health records” and a goat who had a “large, approximately baseball sized tumor” protruding from its neck, writes USDA investigator and veterinarian Marcy Rosendale. The tumor was draining into a shared feeder, “exposing the hay and other animals to the effusion.” A July 13, 2010 investigation said that one goat had a “large open wound to the right hind leg”; the goat had been bitten by a coyote and, Rosendale writes, had “never received any treatment for pain, even prior to wound treatment.”

In 2011, Santa Cruz Biotechnology was under investigation by the USDA for animal welfare violations when a goat with a massive tumor was found being kept alive in order to continue to provide antibodies. In February 2011, a goat was found “wedged in a metal feeder, unable to move its head out of the rungs of the feeder.”

While the USDA typically inspects research and commercial animal facilities once or twice a year, it visited Santa Cruz Biotechnology twelve times in 2012. A “tip-off” led inspectors to find the “remote barn” with 841 goats, some of whom were “lame, anaemic or had protruding bones,” says Nature.

In an email to Nature, Santa Cruz Biotechnology claims that “all animals maintained at the ranch are reported annually to the USDA, including the subject 841 goats” and contends that it is in the process of resolving the dispute. The USDA, though, emphasizes that its “inspectors are very thorough” and that it is a “serious matter” that so many animals were unreported. As neuroscientist Ullan says, “If they don’t know, or neglect to tell the inspector, about 800 animals, it begs questions about how well this company is run and how careful they are in their product line” — with who knows what effects on the research of many labs.


Related Care2 Coverage:

Victory! Military to Stop Torturing Animals for Combat Training

Homeless Goats in the City

Take Action For 3 Sheep That Died Of Thirst At University

Photo from Thinkstock


Manel Dias
Manel Dias4 years ago

Horrible horrible...

Ala Morales
Ala Morales4 years ago

I copy and pasted this article to Governor of Ca. Edmond Brown Jr. Let him know about this SC Biotech Research cruelty and cover up. People have to write to governmental officials. This is the only way that action can be taken.

Liling O4 years ago

I do not understand why some people can be sentenced so lightly like, with a fine when they treated these animals so unbearingly and inhumanely cruel.

If they are given only a fine to pay for what they have done to these poor animals, then I believe they will do even worse things to other animals in future! Who knows they will change?
Who can guarantee???

The US should amends some of its laws to punish these people who lives with no morals

Lisa C.
Lisa Clark4 years ago

I live in Santa Cruz and am horrified to learn this. I sent an email message (because "Animal Health" representatives were reportedly "not available" via Live Chat) to Santa Cruz Biotechnology expressing my disgust. Will there be an on-site protest? Has anything been organized? What can we do?

Alicia N.
Alicia N4 years ago

A fine is good but PLEASE

SHUT that horrible place down for once and for good........... morons!!!!

Marianne Forgo
Marianne Forgo4 years ago


Teresa Wlosowicz
Teresa W4 years ago


Pamela W.
Pamela W4 years ago

Check out the new article about Biotech ..... "Company Abusing and Neglecting Goats While Selling Their Blood" .......... A FINE IS NOT ENOUGH ...... SHUT THEM DOWN !!!!!!

christinanicki g.
.4 years ago

agree with catherine w,jaya s and gina h,noted ,thank you

Linda Jarsky
Linda Jarsky4 years ago

"It is man's sympathy with all creatures that first makes him truly a man --- Dr. Albert Schweitzer..."