Celebrating Indigenous People’s Day and Columbus Day


Until I lived in New Jersey, I had no idea that Columbus Day, which commemorates Christopher Columbus’ arrival in the Americas, could be such a big deal. My son and many other children in New Jersey have the day off from school and there’s a big parade on Fifth Avenue in New York City, along with parades throughout towns in New Jersey. Town halls throughout Hudson County where I work are closed (my college is too) and parking rules are suspended (a big deal if you’ve tried to fit your car into some of Jersey City’s one-way, narrow, car-clogged streets).

Growing up in the 1970s in suburban Contra Costa County in northern California, we did not have the day off from school. We dutifully memorized the names of the Niņa, Pinta and the Santa Maria and who Ferdinand, Isabella and Amerigo Vespucci were. We also learned about why Columbus called the people he encountered “Indians” and, too, about why it was more accurate to say “Native Americans”: They were here first, indeed. Then we learned about Ishi, the last survivor of the Yahi tribe in California. When we studied about the Spanish explorers like Balboa and Cortez and the growth of the missions, we also learned about how Native Americans were forced from their land and died from the diseases the Europeans brought with them.

The idea for Indigenous People’s Day as an alternative, and even a replacement, for Columbus Day occurred in 1977, at a United Nations sponsored conference in Geneva, Switzerland about the discrimination of the indigenous people in the Americas. The first Indigenous People’s Day was celebrated in Berkeley when activists advocated for the Berkeley City Council to declare October 12 “Day of Solidarity with Indigenous People.”

Two other cities in California, Sebastopol and Santa Cruz, also celebrate Indigenous People’s Day while South Dakota and Alabama have renamed the holiday “Native American Day.” Hawaii now celebrates “Discover’s Day,” to commemorate the Polynesian discovers of Hawaii. San Francisco’s Columbus Day Parade is said to be the nation’s oldest continuously existing celebration; it and many other American cities either celebrate “Italian Heritage Day” or have cancelled their observances. Columbus, Ohio, has not celebrated “Columbus Day” since the 1990s, due to the controversy surrounding the Italian explorer’s legacy.

When I’ve mentioned “Indigenous People’s Day” as an alternative to Columbus Day to my students here in New Jersey I’ve gotten a puzzled response (students of Italian heritage easily outnumber students of Native American descent here in New Jersey). They’ve grown up with Columbus Day and celebrations for it and understand the controversy about Columbus, but celebrations for the holiday are well-established. I’m teaching classical mythology this semester and we have been studying some Native American myths, about the creation of the world and Coyote, a trickster figure. Most students have never read about these topics before.

Even if your community still wishes to celebrate “Columbus Day,” shouldn’t celebration of the indigenous people — and mention of the plentiful injustices they have faced — be part of the day’s commemorations?


Related Care2 Coverage

14 Shamans Murdered in Peru

Brazilian Indian Likely Murdered By Cattle Ranchers

Eating Our Cousins: Jane Goodall And The Bushmeat Crisis


Photo by robot


Miranda Lyon
Miranda Lyon4 years ago

1492 (song by Nancy Schimmel)

In fourteen hundred and ninety two
Columbus sailed the ocean blue.
It was a courageous thing to dfo,
But someone was already here.

The Inuit and Cherokee,
the Aztec and Menominee,
Onondaga and the Cree
Columbus sailed across the sea,
But somebody was already here.

Columbus knew the world was round,
So he looked for the East
while westward bound,
But he didn't find
what he though he found,
And someone was already here.

(repeat Chorus after each verse)

It isn't like it was empty space,
Caribs met him face to face,
Could anyone discover the place
When someone was already here?

So tell me who discovered what?
He though he was in a different spot.
Columbus was lost,
the Caribs were not.
They were already here.

(Recorded by Sall Rogers on the CD "Rainbow Sign"; Rounder Records, l992)

Laura T.
Laura T4 years ago

Columbus day celebrates every hate crime against native americans. schools still teach next to nothing about our culture while peddling forign languages&punishing us for speaking our native tongue. I know quite a few who burn Columbus in effigy to what should have happened to an invader&slaver

Aiden A.
Aiden A.4 years ago

what, i had no idea that there was an indigenous people's day! shit, i would've been celebrating that instead of just not celebrating anything at all because i've always known that columbus day was bullshit. if you live in arizona or california or new mexico, would indigenous people's day apply to the mexicans that used to live there before most of them were chased behind the "new" mexican border, or does it only apply to native americans?

Sarah Metcalf
Sarah M6 years ago

Indigenous Day needs to be established as a national holiday and Columbus Day needs to get the boot. I have never and never will celebrate Columbus Day.

Bill K.
Bill K6 years ago

next year boycott any store that has a Columbus Day sale, and let them know why - that you won't support any business that honors a slave trader.

Jay Hem
Immigrant I AM6 years ago

Dont wont celebrate colombus day... will celebrate Indigenous Day

Faith Billingham
Faith Billingham6 years ago

great articles, thanks for sharing

Faith Billingham
Faith Billingham6 years ago

great articles, thanks for sharing

Zoe B.
Zoe B6 years ago

Wyy do folks STILL think columbus "discovered" the americas???

Also, don't people realise that there WERE people living there before the europeans got there, but they killed them off, forced them to move away, and live in camps, beat them, used them as slaves, and whatnot.

Sue H.
.6 years ago

Indigenous Peoples Day works for me. Would never celebrate Colombus