START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
651,392 people care about Real Food

Could Being Overweight Mean a Longer Life?

Could Being Overweight Mean a Longer Life?

January 1 has come and gone, which means many of us have hit the ground running with New Year’s resolutions to eat better or lose weight. Gyms are already selling more memberships as people flood through the doors, eager to fulfill their goals. Living a healthier lifestyle is a popular resolution each year, but what if someone told you that being a little overweight could help you actually live longer? A new study has suggested just that.

Fat Could Help You Live Longer?

It seem counterintuitive, but a new study by Katherine Flegal of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says that being a little overweight – not obese – can decrease your chance of dying by 6 percent. Flegal realizes that this sounds ridiculous. She says she published a paper that came to the same conclusion a few years ago and, “Our article got called rubbish and ludicrous, so it really opens you to lots of criticism. I discovered much to my sorrow that this is kind of a flashpoint for people.” She stands by her study, however, saying that she found over 100 articles with about 3 million people that addressed this question and helped her form her conclusion. How is it possible that fat equals a longer life? Dr. Steven Hymsfield of the Pennington Biomedical Research Center in Baton Rouge posits a few scenarios: a little extra fat could cushion vulnerable bones from a fall, or could help you if a serious disease left you unable to eat.

What the Study Misses

As you might expect, this study isn’t popular and has received much criticism. Walter Willett from the Harvard School of Public Health calls the study “rubbish” and says reading it is a waste of time. He says that the paper only looks at body mass indexes (BMIs) of people and how they influenced the risk of premature death. It does not look at chronic illnesses caused by being overweight, such as heart disease, diabetes, strokes and many other diseases. The research speaks loud and clear on that account – overweight people do experience many more health problems as a result of their weight. The study also does not look at illnesses which cause premature death that might cause someone to become underweight. The link would then have nothing to do with weight and more to do with illness. In short, the study makes some interesting conclusions, but weight shouldn’t have been the only factor Flegal looked at.

It’s Not Always Healthy to Be Underweight or Diet, Either

Willett suggests that, to find a healthy BMI for you, you should look at your weight when you were in your early 20′s, unless you were overweight at that age. However, many changes in our bodies can cause us to gain weight for good reasons. Women, for example, have to gain some weight during pregnancy. For many of us, trying to diet so we can get back to the weight we were at when we were 20 could be just as unhealthy as being a little overweight. According to nutritionist Linda Bacon, Ph.D, “[People] go on fasts, yo-yo diets, detox programs, and ‘cleanses’ without realizing that there are serious consequences to weight loss and nutrient restriction.” Diet programs, if done improperly, can lead to nutrition deficiencies, eating disorders, heart disease, a lowered immune system and many other issues.

Finding a Healthy Weight for You

It’s hard to ignore the weight loss fads and gym advertisements, especially around this time of year. Even if Flegal’s study is flawed, it does help to show us that fat is an okay and necessary part of our bodies. We need fat as a source of stored energy and as insulation and protection for our major organs. Fat even makes up part of the cell membranes for every cell in our body. While it might not be healthy to be overweight, it is healthy to have some fat as part of our bodies and our diet. Beware of dieting and too much exercise. There is such a thing as too much! If we listen to our bodies, they will tell us what they need. If a workout is causing too much pain or exhaustion, you need to stop. If you are craving certain foods, chances are there are nutrients in those foods your body needs. Instead of making a resolution to lose weight this year, resolve to listen to what your body is saying in order to lead a healthier life.


Related Stories

A Better Way to Understand Obesity’s Impact

Are Supermarkets to Blame for the Obesity Epidemic?

Obesity is Bad for Your Body and Your Brain


Read more: , , , , ,

Photo Credit: puuikibeach

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it


+ add your own
7:43PM PDT on May 31, 2013

I'm petite woman 5ft 1in weight 115lbs I don't need anyone to tell me about healthy weight. I've common sense. If I shoved food down my throat & got no exercise I'd be a Human Bowling Ball

11:36AM PDT on Apr 7, 2013


10:28AM PDT on Apr 3, 2013

The BMI is not accurate for many people. If takes for granted that you do not have much muscle tone (which is 2x as heavy as fat) yet people are being told by "professionals that they should be 20 lbs lighter to comply with the BMI. Anyone who has has worked out with heavy weights for a few years would be completely off the BMI scale. The BMI serves one purpose, to keep the experts (most of whom probably need to work out more) happy.

8:49AM PDT on Apr 3, 2013

Perhaps I should eat more chocolate? LOL!

7:12AM PDT on Apr 3, 2013

Thank you for sharing.

3:06AM PDT on Apr 3, 2013

Back in the Sixties when I was a medical student a professor stated these facts to us.In my family it seems to hold true - the thin men died and the plump women survived,me included.The only exception is my mother's always-slim cousin who is now aged 101.

5:09AM PST on Feb 19, 2013

Thank you for the article.

5:20PM PST on Feb 3, 2013

I had heard about this and still don't know, but one thing I know that regardless of our body shape the one thing that we can do is to have the longest quality length of life by thinking positive, doing good, and being kind and doing this all with true happiness.

1:11AM PST on Feb 1, 2013

Very interesting. Today's obsession with being thin at all costs is dangerous. People come in all shapes and sizes, and being within a normal variation will not cause any health problems.

4:41PM PST on Jan 28, 2013

nice read, yes of course healthy weight for you. I have a heavy bone structure, wide ribcage ect. in short i am a stocky guy, and my doctor says I should weigh 160 for my height, but if i did i would look anorexic. i found myself healthiest and more fit at around 180-200 range

add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

That's crazy, I was a nurse, but there were very few men nurses in the 60's & 70's, now there are…

terribly written article as it doesn't explain the why behind the changes. given the slowing of the Gulf…

Send this information to Scott Walker (Rep. Presidential Candidate). He claims and called all food stamp…

meet our writers

Steve Williams Steve Williams is a passionate supporter of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Trans (LGBT) rights, human... more
ads keep care2 free

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.