German Catholic Group Offers Homeopathic ‘Cure’ for Homosexuality

It was revealed this week that a Catholic association of doctors in Germany has been advertising a homeopathic “cure” for homosexuality on its website, much to the outrage of LGBT rights groups in the country.

Billed as “Therapy Options for Homosexuality” the Union of Catholic Physicians (UCP), which reportedly calls itself the Catholic voice for the medical community, says that while homosexuality is not an illness, there can be a variety of treatments to keep those “inclinations” at bay.

More from SPIEGEL Online International:

Possibilities include “constitutional treatments with homeopathic tools … such as homeopathic dilutions like Platinum,” “psychotherapy,” and “religious counseling.” Among homeopathy’s controversial treatments are the prescription of “Globuli,” tiny pills that consisting mostly of sugar.

“We know about a number of people with homosexual feelings who find themselves in a spiritual and psychological emergency and suffer greatly,” UCP head Gero Winkelmann told SPIEGEL in a written statement. “If someone is unhappy, ill or feels they are in an emergency, they should be able to find options for help with us.”

But the doctor, who runs a private practice with an emphasis on homeopathy in the Bavarian town of Unterhaching, also stressed that the UCP website had not been recently updated, “because the issue is not particularly topical at the moment.”

As for the scientific basis of the treatments offered by the UCP, Winkelmann listed “medical-psychotherapeutic, philosophical and theological literature,” the “minority views of psychotherapists,” the “teachings of the Catholic church, the Holy Scripture,” and the “homeopathy of Samuel Hahnemann,” the German physician credited with creating the practice.

The overwhelming majority of the medical community rejects reparative or gay “cure” therapy, while a sizable proportion also questions the efficaciousness of homeopathy.

LGBT rights groups including the Lesbian and Gay Federation in Germany have said that this supposed treatment preys on vulnerable lesbian and gay people or those questioning their sexuality, seemingly offering them a solution to their anxiety that will ultimately prove fruitless and could potentially lead to further trauma.

The Catholic association, while reiterating that this is a private opinion, says that they are offering this treatment not because of intolerance but rather as a contribution to an “age-old issue.”

From The Local, Germany’s News in English:

The LSVD has branded the “therapy” as unacceptable. “The offers are dangerous,” spokeswoman Renate Rampf told the magazine. “They exploit the insecurities of homo- and bisexual young people and their parents.”

Rampf also said the treatments would be especially destabilizing because they couldn’t work. “All serious specialists in the area agree that sexual orientation is shaped in earliest childhood,” she said.

Winkelmann insisted that his organization was not trying to hurt or “impose” an illness on anyone. He also clarified that his website did not present the official Catholic church view of homosexuality, but was a private opinion.

“This is not about outing or intolerance,” a statement on the website reads. “It’s a Christian and medical contribution to an age-old issue.”

To me, this does not qualify as a medical contribution and it is intellectually dishonest for Winkelmann or his association to pretend that it is.

in August of 2009, the American Psychological Association officially adopted a resolution reaffirming its stance against conversion therapy and sexual orientation “change efforts” after carrying out a rigorous examination of 83 conversion therapy studies from peer-reviewed journals dated between 1960 to 2007.

The panel found that only a handful of the studies, few of which were carried out in the last decade, could be considered methodologically sound, and that none had “systematically evaluated [the] potential harms” of conversion therapy.

As such, the APA drew up the “Resolution on Appropriate Affirmative Responses to Sexual Orientation Distress and Change Effects” in which it warns that therapists must not misrepresent the success rate of such therapy, which remains negligible, or gloss over the potential harms of conversion attempts, which are considerable and in several instances have led to attempted suicides. The resolution therein recommends that conversion therapy should be rejected as a viable course of treatment in favor of counseling to help patients reconcile their feelings regarding sexual orientation. Read more about the APA’s 2009 resolution here.

The APA did not consider homeopathic “cures” for homosexuality in the above resolution but it can be reasonably assumed it would maintain its stance against conversion therapy.

Photo used under the Creative Commons Attribution License, with thanks to incurable_hippy.


William Y.
William Y6 years ago

@ François T. Homosexuality is only a problem when one makes it one. Homosexuality is not a disease or mental condition. Homosexuality is only a sin when ignorant people attempt to put dark ages mentality to modern times. One cannot change his/her sexual preference any more than one can change his/her skin color.

François T.
François T.6 years ago

Homosexuality is a problem. It was very common before there was christianity and it was very normal. But the moral life of the people was really bad at this time. Christianity brought morality and changed the world. I'm not saying everyone was perfect, we are all not perfect, but Christ came to save the sinner. Sorry but, the Catholic Church is helping homosexuals to be liberated from their immoral life, if they practice homosexuality, by showing the good path. Also, those catholics in the article, are helping homosexuals. Many homosexuals can witness that what the Church teaches about sexuality, liberated them from sin and brought them the real peace.

Joy Jin
Joy Jin6 years ago

This is so stupid. There is no cure for Homosexuality. It's not a disease!

Martha Eberle
Martha Eberle6 years ago

Again, the Catholic Church, that beacon that shines, continues to live in the 12th century.

tia pearson
tia pearson6 years ago

From what I understand, there isn't a homeopathic cure' for homosexuality. Platinum, for instance, is used for treating sadness, lamenting or feelings of separation. Sounds as if the church is trying to address issues that could affect anyone. The church may see that a particular group of people have these issues more than other groups and I am not saying that one group of people have these issues more than others but that the church may see it that way.

Homeopathic pills are just sugar pills with informational energy. Once information that the body is lacking (hence a disease) is given, the body corrects itself (hence healing). There are no side effects to this process except if you don't have what the remedy is treating, you will get it until you stop taking that remedy. My family and friends have benefitted from homeopathy in that it is very inexpensive, it works within a very short time (sometimes a day) and there isn't any side effects.
Homeopathy may not work for everyone or for every disease but I haven't found anything within medical science that works without side effects of some sort (especially to the kidneys and liver).

KrassiAWAY B.
Krasimira B6 years ago

Agree Tony! What a bunch of MORONS!

Adam G.
Adam G6 years ago

they should look for a "cure" for religion & paedophilia, since those are the afflictions they are truly suffering from...

Olga R.
Olga R.6 years ago

Thank you for the comments! Juliet D. I am still laughing! The homeopathic formula for homosexuality seems right on! and Joseph Belisle, I so agree there is hope! we may be able to become heartless and with a homeopathic remedy, that is awesome. Thank you for the laughs!! :))

Jackie Agusta
Jackie Agusta6 years ago

What a load of crap, just another despearate attempt by the Catholic church to claw back a few followers, people who preach this nonsence should be arrested :-(

Tony Co
Tony C6 years ago

What a bunch of MORONS