Jewish Father Protests Cremation of Son


Recently, the tragic suicide of Florida teen Aaron Tabachnik has led to court controversy. Tabachnik’s funeral arrangements were originally left to his mother’s discretion and included cremation. Tabachnik’s mother hoped to honor her son by cremating his body, and then spreading his ashes in Arad, Israel where the family originally hails from. However, Tabachnik is of the Jewish faith and, after hearing about the plans, his father took action to prevent the cremation in favor of a more traditional burial. To help ensure that Aaron received a Jewish burial, Rabbi Isaac Leider put together a petition at Rabbi Leider further offered his insights concerning Aaron’s burial, and helped shed light on the issue of cremating members of the Jewish faith.

1. What is the issue surrounding Aaron Tabachnik’s funeral arrangements?
The issue is that it is one of the most basic aspects of Jewish Law that a Jew must be buried whole. In addition to this, it is the father’s wishes that Aaron be buried according to Jewish Law. Therefore, the court, in allowing Aaron’s proper burial, would not only be ruling for religious freedom, but respecting the wishes of Aaron’s father in his time of grief.

2. Why is it problematic for Aaron’s body to be cremated?
Nothing is more important to Jewish tradition that a Jew’s body be buried whole. Cremation is the worst type of violation of Jewish Law. In addition, it would cause the father unnecessary additional grief if Aaron’s body were cremated.

3. What is the importance of a proper Jewish burial?
Jews believe that a person’s body belongs to G-d. When a Jew dies, he must return his body to G-d whole. Further, Jews believe that in a time of future Redemption, G-d will restore the bodies of the righteous to life. Therefore, it is essential that a Jew be buried properly, according to Jewish Law.

4. Why do you feel that this issue is so important?
Because the issue is such a central issue in Jewish Law, allowing Aaron’s body to be [cremated] would go against the American tradition of religious freedom and would be wrong because it would cause pain to the father.

The issue of Aaron’s burial is an incredibly sensitive one. Both of Aaron’s parents want the best for their son and want to honor his memory. We know that his parents will do whatever they can to ensure that their son’s faith and wishes are respected. We wish his family and friends the best in overcoming the aftermath of this tragedy.

Related Stories:

Would You Swim in a Pool Heated by a Crematorium?

Lower Your Impact On Nature When You Die

Judge Strikes San Francisco Circumcision Ban From the Ballot

Photo by pboyd04 via Flickr


DeeDee D.
DeeDee D.3 years ago

Moshe tabachnik is not Aaron's father not mine and not Danny's. He's a man who didn't know Aaron's own birthday in court. Doesn't know it period

Sheri P.
Sheri P6 years ago

If G-d will restore the bodies of the righteous to life then what's the problem? Can't G-d restore any body? What difference does it make if the body was cremated or naturally decomposed?

Jackie Agusta
Jackie Agusta6 years ago

Very sad story :-(

colleen p.
colleen p6 years ago

we still have people believing they need body for afterlife or a reboot of the world. I thought that died out with mummification.

Teresa Wlosowicz
Teresa W6 years ago

Perhaps the Jews are so much against cremation because they associate it with the Holocaust?

Treesa Math
tia Math6 years ago

God be with the family

Tom Y.
Tom Y6 years ago

I wanted burial for my father after he died, but my Mom and brothers overruled me. Cremation was cheaper, took up less land and the "ashes" could be interred in a garden at the cemetery. What we got was a plastic bag of grist inside a wooden box of an urn, and a little hole excavated in a flower bed by a city employee. It was all too small an end for the man my Dad was. I'll be taking burial when it's my turn.

As for "ryan b" and his offensive claim that "You religious people are all fanatic, weakminded fools," the only fanatic I've seen on this board is him. Nobody likes a pushy, insensitive atheist attempting flawgical ego-boosting on the backs of other people's grief.

Susan Freiman
susan Freiman6 years ago

There are cremations of Jews in Israel.

Robert O.
Robert O6 years ago

I wish the family the best in this complicated matter.

Alicia N.
Alicia N6 years ago

Good luck to this family and
R. I. P.............. Aaron