NC Anti-Gay Amendment Heads to the Ballot


The North Carolina Senate on Tuesday passed a measure that if approved by voters would write an existing statutory ban on same-sex marriage into the state’s constitution.

On Monday, ten Democrats voted with nearly all House Republicans to pass the amendment in a 75-42 vote. Tuesday’s Senate vote came down to a 30-16 majority, over the three fifths needed to send the question to the voters in a May 8, 2012, referendum.

More from Reuters:

State Senator Dan Soucek, a Republican and sponsor of the amendment, said it was necessary to protect marriage between a man and a woman as the “time-tested building block of society.”

Senator Ellie Kinnaird, a Democrat, said the amendment was about the oppression of gay people.

“What we are doing here is making a situation that is difficult for many people much, much worse,” she said.

The action by lawmakers was both praised and panned. Several hundred gay rights advocates protested the amendment at a noon rally outside the Legislative Building in Raleigh.

Democratic Gov. Bev Perdue is said to have expressed disappointment that the Legislature is “wasting time” with the marriage amendment, however the governor is not capable of vetoing this measure due to the procedural rules surrounding constitutional amendments.

LGBT rights advocates warned that the measure is unnecessarily divisive, and indeed the marriage amendment seems to have brought out some ugliness and also touched on some old but still exposed wounds:

State Rep. Marcus Brandon, R-Guilford, the only openly gay state lawmaker, told his fellow lawmakers that people yelled “abomination” at him as he walked through the capitol building that afternoon, and said he was told he was “going to hell.”

State Rep. Mickey Michaux, D-Durham, a black lawmaker, took the floor and shared that the U.S. constitution “still says I am three-fifths of a person.” Michaux said on the floor that he was attempting to highlight how hard it would be to remove the discriminatory language in the future.

Read more: Richmond County Daily Journal – NC voters will see same sex marriage ban on ballot

The May referendum was a Republican concession to secure Democrat votes in the Housed who didn’t want the November elections to be affected by the conservative draw of the marriage amendment.

This, however, may have given those opposed to gay marriage a slight advantage when the measure goes to the ballot.

From The Advocate:

Social conservatives might have a slight advantage in getting out their voters because the referendum will have the same date as the Republican Party’s presidential primary.

“Politically scheming to put such a cruel and discriminatory measure on a low-turnout Republican presidential primary ballot is a sham designed to circumvent the majority of North Carolina voters, who polls say, oppose this amendment and the injury it will inflict not just on families, but the state,” said Marc Solomon, national campaign director for Freedom to Marry.

Holding the vote in May also means that by the time the Democrats arrive in September (with the world’s media in tow) for their national party convention, the state could be reeling from the effect of a vote on civil rights.

Recent polls have suggested that a majority of North Carolinians are against the marriage amendment, seeing it as unnecessary and discriminatory because it would appear to invalidate all chance of civil unions and domestic partnership rights — indeed, one lawyer has warned that the ban could upset an entire plethora of state partnership rights and perhaps even disturb domestic violence legislation. That said, how people poll prior to a ballot and how they choose to vote when it comes to actual voting day are two different things and same-sex marriage has never won at the ballot, though the margin by which it has lost had narrowed significantly when advocates lost in Maine in 2009. Maine of course is now preparing to put the issue before voters again with a renewed confidence that it will pass.

North Carolina’s prospects, as the only Southern state not to have a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage, seem less assured but advocates of LGBT rights and wider equality advocates feel there is still a fight to be had and that fair minded North Carolinians will do the right thing.

Related Reading:

NC Rep: Gay Marriage Philosophically Same as Incest, Polygamy

NC Gay Marriage Ban Destined for Special Session

University’s Gay Friendly Church List Riles Professor

Image used under the Creative Commons Attribution License with thanks to netsu.


Duane B.
.5 years ago

Thank you for sharing.

kenny s.
Kenny Stidham6 years ago

@ Albert M....Then all 'big' religion is all wrong. Dont be so insulting. That is abnormal behavior. People are born gay. Learn it. Know it. Accept it. Ban the christian religion. Execute all who take part in this sick twisted hate group. christianity IS going down.

Winn Adams
Winn A6 years ago

The state of North Carolina needs to come out of the dark ages.

Sally Giffney
Sally Giffney6 years ago

When is this kind of thing going to stop? There is nothing wrong with homosexuality! Gays are human too, you know.

Christopher Fowler

Bans like this have already been defeated in court repeatedly, on Constitutional grounds. Every state's constitution is mandated to be in compliance with the US Constitution. This ban, like the one that was shot down in CA, are in violation of the 14th amendment clause of equal protection in the US Constitution.

If the (extremist Christian) lawmakers can't see that, then it is time for NC to hire politicians that will stand up, unwaveringly, for the principle that make this country a great nation.

Heather O.
Heather O6 years ago

The US is a free country supposedly. All tax paying legal citizens in the US should have their right to choose their partner, even if people don't like it. It is your right to choose who you love. And if you are a contributing citizen to our gov then you should be able to marry who you want regardless of same sex or not. Just because your against it doesn't mean your opinion is right. But we are a free nation and it is their right.

Bruce Van Tassell

Hopefully a few people will put away the hoods and burning crosses for one day.

Hunter W.
Hunter W6 years ago

It's too common that people use religion as a justification for their discriminatory behavior. So i can't help but wonder, if nobody on earth was religious, do you think they would still be racist and discriminate against others? If so, what do you think their reasons for their actions would be? Hmm.
Very unfortunate that lawmakers are bringing a religious view into government. Whatever happened to separation of church and state? The whole idea between a marriage being "sacred and reserved for a man and woman" has religious origins!

Debra Van Way
Debra Van Way6 years ago

I have to agree with Duane B. I have lived in the "Bible belt" a couple of times. Found it to be the most hate filled place in the country. I have been shot at by a sniper in Mississippi on my way to work and threatened by some white guys while trying to eat breakfast at a little resturant in Charleston, SC. I was in uniform (AF during Viet Nam), am white and straight. Those folks hate everyone seemingly. All the nice people I met there were either black, Native American or from somewhere else.

Terry T.
Terry T6 years ago

Sorry Dawid, DOMA is nothing but hatred toward the LGBT people.