Police Officers Torture Man on Accident, Now Granted Pardon

Written by Lourdes Sada, translated by Anna Williams

On July 27, 2006, Romanian citizen Lucian Paduraru and his pregnant wife left their Barcelona home when five men approached the couple and attacked Paduraru, beating him viciously. The five men were members of the Catalan police force Mossos d’Esquadra [en], but never identified themselves to the couple. The officers had mistaken Paduraru for a notoriously dangerous mugger.

Paduraru was arrested and taken to the police station in Les Corts where the beating not only continued, but worsened to include threats, insults, and even inserting the barrel of a gun into his mouth. It was only when one of the mossos realized security cameras monitored the room that the beating stopped. The tragedy turned graver still with the realization that Paduraru is a hemophiliac. This case served as one of the examples in Amnesty International’s Spain: Adding insult to injury [en] report about police violence in Spain.

The five mossos faced charges of torture, personal injury and illegal detention and were tried in Barcelona’s main court. Three officers received a six year and seven month sentence each, one received a two year and three month sentence and the fifth received only a fine for abuse. In an appeal to the Supreme Court, the sentences were reduced and granted a suspension pending the final outcome of the police investigation for the pardon the mossos requested.

In February 2012, the government granted the first pardon claiming “subsequent police investigations” provided “new and valuable information in relation to the facts of the case.” They also took into account the officers’ personal records with the department as well as “the mounting support and general backing for the pardon.” The pardon further reduced the prison times, to two years, which coupled with their lack of prior offenses exempted the officers from their return to prison. In addition, their banning from public office was also substituted for a two year suspension.

In spite of this, the Court made the unusual mandate that the officers fulfill their prison time, citing social outrage and the threat the officers posed to society. In response, the mossos filed their second appeal.

Yet a few days ago, the Spanish government, ignoring public opinion, granted the officers’ second appeal, commuting their prison time to a mere fine of 7,200 euros (roughly $9,350) to be paid 10 euro “installments” over two years.

This secondary pardon has enraged the public, who has widely interpreted the government’s action as a clear siding with the impunity and brutality that blatantly violated fundamental human rights. On Twitter, the hashtags #indulto [pardon] and #justiciadeespaña [justice in Spain] became the trending topics the afternoon of the announcement. Abraham Escobar of #14N and Gloria Marcos shared their indignation:

@gloriamarcosmar: Gano Ping freed, torturers pardoned, the #PP [Popular Party] promotes police brutality. What country do we live in? #JusticiaDeEspaña

Ricardo Sixto criticized the Ministry of Justice’s recent initiatives:

@Rsixtoiglesias: Spain: it pardons torturers and uses fines as a means of justice. There is no rule of law. http://www.publico.es/espana/446355/

This pardon sheds light on the reality of what has been happening for years. Spaniards are beginning to realize that the pardon, a mechanism intended to humanize justice, has been used extensively by the government to overturn the sentences of offenders in close proximity to power. Ignacio Escobar explains as much in his article “The pardon: A daily abuse of power“:

[…] we are one of the Western countries whose government abuses most this arbitrary prerogative. Since 1977 we have granted 17,620 pardons, according to the BOE [State Official Bulletin, en]. Among those pardoned are the best of each house: the leaders of the 23-F coup [coup of February 23, 1981, en], the GAL terrorists [Grupos Antiterroristas de Liberación, en], corrupt politicians, depraved judges, big businesses, fraudulent bankers, drug traffickers… This averages to 480 each year.

Zapatero granted 3,226 during his two years while Aznar —national record holder— nearly doubled this number with 5,916 pardons. By comparison, George W. Bush granted only 200 pardons in eight years in the United States, a country seven times the size of Spain […]

Nearly 200 judges united to sign a declaration of dissent against the mossos‘ pardon. The following are excerpts from the press release:

A pardon assumes an act in violation of human dignity whose responsibility in the persecution of said acts of torture falls on the State or the hands of its agents.


Torture is one of the worst possible ways in which human dignity is violated. This dignity is the foundation of a constitutional order. The European Court of Human Rights has condemned Spain for not investigating these acts. […] When the [Ministry of] Justice acts, investigates and condemns, the Government pardons. It then becomes challenging to explain such behavior before the European Court.


The Government’s decision is unbecoming of a democratic system of law, illegitimate, and ethically unaffordable.

The Minister of Justice, Alberto Ruiz Gallardón, defended the Government’s decision:

[…] what cannot prevail is the belief that other powers can assume certain faculties that are not theirs just because the constitution grants them to the state of Spain; the pardon is not a right of the judiciary but a faculty of the executive power.

But there is still hope that this pardon will count for something, as Ixaiac writes in a Huffington Post article:

Yesterday the SUP [Unified Police Union], today 200 judges. Maybe something is changing. But for most, the change comes too late. Hopefully more and more eyes are being opened to the constant abuse of power. Let’s waste no time in restoring justice to our society.

This post was originally published by Global Voices.


Related Stories:

Why Was A Naked 18-Year-Old Shot Dead By Police?

Innocent Deaf Woman Tasered By Tacoma Police

Man Killed While Handcuffed in Squad Car, Cops Say Suicide


Photo: conner395/flickr


Khannea Suntzu
Khannea Sun Tzu6 years ago

The outcome if this legal travesty will be very sad and very grim. This will result in dead Spanish cops. Cop corpses littering the Spanish backstreets, faces shot so the family will have to bury their beloved cops family members in a closed casket. Cops should realize this will result in dead cops and they will have no one to blame but themselves. Justice MUST be served, one way or another.

Annmari Lundin
Annmari Lundin6 years ago

Maybe someone comes across these lowlifes and "by accident" something bad happens to them. Karma's a bi-atch!

Klaus Peters
Klaus Peters6 years ago

How can anybody trust the Spanish police, government and court of law. Disgusting, bad loosers just like Fernando Alonzo, but I love his sour face after defeat. He looks like a tortured bull, but for his benefit I hate bull fighting.

Lynn D.
Lynn D6 years ago

Horrible! should have never happened doesn't help this family at all!

Michelle Knight
Michelle Knight6 years ago

How did 5 Police Officers "ACCIDENTALLY" torture a Man over a period of time/without having a positive identification/ and until they realized they were being video taped? That would be like claiming to accidentally spit in someones face after you called their name so they would turn around! This was VERY EVIDENTLY a case of mistaken identity, but the torture was purposeful!!!!! Spain has an Extremely skewed view of what justice is!!! I bet the people could ALL come up with a definitive plan of action for justice had it been themselves or a Family Member or loved one who had the crap beaten out of themselves, MISTAKENLY!!!!!!!!!!

Patricia H.
Patricia H.6 years ago


Kamryn M.
Kay M6 years ago


Winn Adams
Winn A6 years ago

This is crazy . . . . .

Lynette Harrison
Lynette Harrison6 years ago

Sorry -- not going to read this article because the title includes the words "...on accident." That is categorically incorrect on every level -- it shows ignorance in writing and should never have been printed.

Kay Caldwell

Oh, I guess it wouldn't have been an accident if they had been beating the correct person? This sounds like the case where a surgeon I used to work with asked a doctor from South America about malpractice in his country and the doctor replied "Malpractice, malpractice? We don't have malprcatice, we have guns." They can get away with so much more in foreign countries than we can here in the good old USA. Although, the police have been known to used to much force here too. It is a crying shame!!