Sensationalist Media Reports About Kanye West’s Mental Health Must Stop

Aside from his record-breaking work in both the music and fashion industries, Kanye West has always been a colorful media personality — and never expressed fear of speaking his mind. However, in the past few months, several incidents have created media speculation about West’s mental health.

For example, his recent statements surrounding Facebook, Hillary Clinton and friend Jay Z — as well as his conduct during live performances — have led media to call his behavior “bizarre.” Some have even questioned whether West is entirely healthy, noting the recent pressures affecting his family.

People close to West stated that his most recent tour left him exhausted. He has since pulled out of all remaining dates on the Saint Pablo tour.

On November 22, it emerged that West had been taken to hospital after emergency services were alerted to a disturbance at his home. West, who was described as “medically stable” by the authorities, was then admitted to UCLA Medical Center.

Despite the fact that at the time of writing neither West, his family nor his representatives have commented on his hospital stay, the media has decided that West’s recent behavior and this hospital stay are connected.

For example, take this headline from the Daily Mail:

Kanye’s ‘psychiatric emergency’: West’s doctor ‘feared he’d attack cops who came to hospitalize screaming rapper in cuffs’ during psychotic episode that forced Kim to cancel comeback

In its extensive summary of its own story, the Mail also says:

  • Kanye reportedly tried to resist paramedics and had to be handcuffed to a gurney while being transported
  • Friends say the ‘breakdown’ was triggered by marital problems, a rift with Jay Z and jealousy of Beyoncé

The Mail goes on to state in its opening paragraph:

Kanye West’s doctor feared he would hurt police as he allegedly screamed about people trying to kill him and had hallucinations while he had a psychotic break at his personal trainer’s house, it has been revealed. 

The rest of the article, which is lengthy, contains images and several “reports” from unnamed and named sources about the events surrounding West’s move to the hospital for treatment. The Mail uses medical terms like “nervous breakdown” and “psychotic break” interchangeably and imprecisely that suggest simple speculation and a lack of facts.

Unfortunately, the idea that West has suffered a “psychotic break” or was displaying “psychotic behavior” has flooded the more gossip-heavy websites.

Perez Hilton tries to absolve himself by putting the term in quotations before delving into more speculation, while the Mirror and others have simply repeated the label without offering any context at all.

The very fact that the media is indulging in this feeding frenzy demonstrates how society treats mental health differently from physical health problems.

When the media forensically dissects what may have happened to West, voyeurism is at work. This is the same approach the media used to cover Britney Spears during her much publicized struggles in 2007 — and still does today. It’s also similar to the salacious headlines surrounding the ill-health and death of singer Amy Winehouse, to name but a few examples.

In this case, the Daily Mail managed a tour-de-force of terrible reporting that is stigmatizing. It then attempts to cover itself by including tweets of celebrity well wishes, but here’s the thing: when any media outlet makes a show out of a person’s mental health issues, it stands to do real damage.

People may be even more reluctant to seek treatment and be open about their mental health struggles in the first place.

Men, in particular, struggle to open up about mental health issues. Due to enforced gender norms, men are often taught that they should not express their feelings, and they are often made almost deathly afraid of appearing weak.

While we would not splash the details of someone’s physical health problems across media sites, we have a very different approach to mental health. It enforces the notion that speaking out and seeking help or treatment can come with serious professional and personal consequences.

While arguably it is in the public interest to report on West’s hospitalization due to his position as a cultural figure, the details of his condition and the reasons why he was admitted should not be up for discussion.

To out West as having mental health issues — and to do so absent of the full facts — is deeply wrong. Furthermore, the media’s release of the emergency service call relating to West’s hospitalization is clearly a step too far.

What we have here is a perfect example of how the media preys upon mentally ill people to sell stories about the so-called “damaged” or “disturbed.” This is a terrible facet of the industry that makes pain and tears part of its brand.

Media outlets must be held accountable for the real harm they can do to people who are already in a vulnerable position of mental ill-health.

Photo credit: Kim Erlandsen.


Kellyanne M
Kellyanne Mabout a year ago

I don't care for Kanye West and his silly antics, but if he is ill he does deserve privacy.

Siyus Copetallus
Siyus Copetallusabout a year ago

Thank you for sharing.

Past Member
Past Member about a year ago

Mina X. So do racist anti semetic Republitards like Mel Gibson and biggest whore in Hollywood. Charlie Sheen. TRUMP SUPPORTERS. LONG list of them.

Past Member
Past Member about a year ago

Meqdad. Looks like you do not have half a brain. Some of the biggest whores in Hollywood are Republitards and racists. Or racist Republitards.

Past Member
Past Member about a year ago

Lisa M. This is why i call them the KarTRASHians.Not to worry. Ratings are way down.

Chris Ringgold
Chris Ringgoldabout a year ago

Mental Health is just as serious as (or in many cases, even more serious than) Physical Health. While People should definitely seek help for Mental Health Issues, they shouldn't have to be subjected to "targets" and "exploitation" from News Media Outlets.

Naomi Dreyer
Naomi Dreyerabout a year ago

News paper and media people have to earn a living writing something every day. To bad I'm not interested.

Margie FOURIEabout a year ago

I agree with Julie W.

Julie W.
Julie Wabout a year ago

Kanye and Kim? Yawn!

Ron B.
Ron Babout a year ago

Why is Care2 devoting any space to this character? So he's got problems, huh? Well hey, we've all got problems---and they're about to get much worse. Care2, please don't ever ask us to keep up with the Kardashians on your site.