Success! North Carolina Fails to Criminalize Whistleblowers

In a victory for us and animals, North Carolina lawmakers have officially gone on break without passing an ag gag bill that would have criminalized whistleblowers for exposing cruelty to animals on factory farms.

It’s not hard to see why the industry is trying so desperately to keep the public from seeing what goes on behind closed doors on farms. Numerous undercover investigations conducted by animal advocacy organizations have exposed shocking levels of cruelty to animals at farms in the state over the past few years.

Mercy for Animals uncovered severe cruelty to turkeys at Butterball farms in 2011, 2012 and again this past June when it exposed the heartbreaking treatment newborn turkeys are regularly exposed to at hatcheries.

The organization’s investigation in 2011 resulted in a raid that led to animal cruelty charges and convictions, including the first-ever felony cruelty conviction involving birds used in food production, and the ousting of a top official from the state’s Department of Agriculture over obstruction of justice charges.

Unfortunately, Butterball wasn’t the only business in the spotlight. Earlier this summer Compassion Over Killing exposed the sickening treatment of broiler chickens at Prince Poultry, a supplier for Pilgrim’s Corp., which is the second largest chicken producer in the world. Workers were seen abusing chickens and getting rid of unwanted birds by dumping them alive in outdoor pits where they were left to die a slow death among the bodies of others like trash. Not only did this investigation expose cruelty, but also the debilitating health consequences that come with forcing chickens raised for meat to grow too fast.

Worse, in this case is that the state doesn’t even consider this a crime, and will not be bringing any charges.

Depressingly, instead of tackling these issues in a meaningful way, lawmakers instead tried to pass legislation that would punish those who brought these horrors to light. This isn’t just a problem for animals who are left to suffer out of the public eye, it’s also a problem for us as consumers who have a right to know where our food is coming from so we can make informed choices and decide whether this is an industry we want to keep supporting.

Lawmakers tried to pass a similar version last year, but failed then too. The most recent bill, known as the Commerce Protection Act, was considered even more dangerous than the previous version because it went beyond the realm of farms and would have effectively shut down whistleblowers from all industries.

Thanks in part to efforts from animal advocacy organizations and others that oppose ag gag legislation, in addition to the public’s response more than 47,000 of you signed the Care2 petition asking lawmakers to oppose this bill the state failed again to get it done.

MFA notes that lawmakers will meet again later this year when this legislation could be reconsidered so we’ll have to watch to see what happens, but for now it’s another victory in the battle against anti-whistleblower legislation. Hopefully North Carolina’s lawmakers will let this one go and start working on something useful, instead of wasting our tax dollars on efforts to shield abusers from accountability and public scrutiny at the expense of animal welfare, consumer safety and the First Amendment.

Photo credit: Thinkstock


Mark K.
Mark K1 years ago

Common sense prevailed this time.

Jim Ven
Jim Ven2 years ago

thanks for the article.

Valerie A.
Valerie A3 years ago

signed, thanks

sandra vito
Sandra Vito3 years ago

no nos pueden callar!! una victoria y a por muchas mas

Lea Silhol
Lea Silhol3 years ago


Loesje vB
Loesje Najoan3 years ago

Good news!!! Thank you for sharing.

Bill Eagle
Bill Eagle3 years ago

We need to pass "Shield Laws" to protect whistle blowers, not Ag Gag Bills.
Ag Gag laws and similar legislation would not succeed if we could just get big money out of politics. Unless we do, we can kiss what little Democracy we have good bye.

pam w.
pam w3 years ago

I'd be more than happy to test the ''ag gag'' laws. And I expect organizations such as ACLU will be happy to help test them, too.

The idea that people can abuse animals in such a HEINOUS way is unacceptable!

Arlene C.
Arlene C3 years ago

Bravo à nous tous

Dawn W.
Dawnie W3 years ago

Sounds about right...Lets get the good bloke and string him up and let all the wrong doers loose to repeat the cycle. What sort of horse play is loose here? "Fair dinkum!" It's lunacy. Where has goodness, honesty and humanity, for all living beings gone? Seems to have left some peoples shores long ago and will never be seen again. God help us all.

💕ღƸ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ☻And♥now these three♥remain☻Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒღ💕
💕♥☻ღ💕•★• ღ♥Faith♥Hope♥Love♥ ღ•★•💕 ღ☻♥💕
💕ღƸ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄ƷღBut the greatest of these is loveღƸ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒღ💕
Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ♥☻★Love☻ღ*★♥love♥★*ღ☻love ★☻♥Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ
💕♥*♥˚☻Love & Peace☻go with☻you all.☻˚♥*♥💕