The Bottom Line: A Solution to Protect Threatened Tuna

Note: This is a guest post from Lee Crockett, Director of U.S. Fisheries Campaigns at the Pew Environment Group.

An innovative project in the Gulf of Mexico may finally offer a real solution to a decades-old problem.

For 30 years, fisheries experts at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) have tried to protect western Atlantic bluefin tuna from surface longlines in the Gulf of Mexico, the severely depleted fish’s only known spawning area. Yet despite those efforts, this gear, intended to catch yellowfin tuna and swordfish, still threatens bluefin and other ocean wildlife.

Fishermen and scientists may finally have a solution to the problem. Since May 2012, they have been working together on a year-long pilot program to test greenstick gear and buoy gear, which are alternative fishing methods seen as potential replacements for surface longlines in the Gulf. Initial results indicate that the new gear is more effective at catching the targeted species and, even more important, the increasing catch rates for each successive trip suggest that the equipment can be made even more effective over time. If adopted throughout the Gulf, these more selective fishing methods could provide significant environmental and economic benefits to the region.

A greenstick is a 35- to 45-foot pole attached to the top of a boat that tows a 300- to 400-foot line. Up to 10 plastic squid baits hang from the line and skip across the water, mimicking real squid and flying fish, both common prey of yellowfin tuna. Once a fish is hooked, it’s quickly brought to the boat.

Buoy gear, a relatively simple piece of fishing equipment developed for targeting swordfish, consists of a single piece of heavy fishing line attached to one or two hooks on one end and a buoy with a light on the other. Generally, one vessel will use 12 to 15 pieces of this free-floating gear. The buoys, which are deployed at night, drift in a straight line with the current. When a fish takes the bait, it drags a buoy out of line, indicating that it has been hooked.

Surface longlines, by comparison, stretch for 30 miles on average and suspend approximately 750 baited hooks. These hooks are often left in the water for up to 18 hours and catch a wide variety of ocean wildlife, in addition to the targeted species.

Fishermen monitor greenstick gear and buoy gear and land fish quickly. If the catch is too small or not the right species, they quickly release it. This dramatically reduces the mortality of juveniles and any fish not kept for sale.

Researchers with the Oceanographic Center at Nova Southeastern University (NSU) in Dania Beach, Fla., are recruiting commercial fishermen in the Gulf to test greenstick fishing for yellowfin tuna and buoy gear fishing for swordfish. Two vessels from Florida are experimenting with the new equipment. A vessel fishing out of Louisiana is expected to start using the alternative gear later this month, and another Florida-based vessel is expected to join the project in October.

Fishermen who have worked with swordfish buoy gear and greensticks in other areas (the Outer Banks of North Carolina and the Florida Straits) are training the new participants to help them become skilled with the equipment and methods, including adapting the gear to the Gulf fisheries.

NSU has also assembled several trained fisheries observers to collect data on the catch and economics of the alternative gear. This information will allow scientists and fishermen to analyze gear effectiveness in multiple locations and during different seasons. Researchers will use economic data collected by the observers to compare the income and expenses associated with surface longlines with those of the alternative gear.

Data from this pilot program could be especially timely, given that NOAA is reviewing the way it manages bluefin tuna fishing in U.S. waters. The agency is developing a new bluefin rule, which is expected in early 2014. It is seriously considering promoting the transition from surface longlines to greensticks and swordfish buoy gear and prohibiting the use of surface longlines year-round in the Gulf.

If greenstick and buoy gear in the Gulf perform as well as expected, NOAA could finally have a viable, practical and economical alternative to surface longlines. Switching gear could finally halt the wasteful killing of ocean wildlife such as bluefin and sailfish, while ensuring profitable jobs for U.S. commercial fishermen and consumer access to American-caught seafood for decades to come — a win-win for all the communities that depend on a healthy and vibrant marine ecosystem in the Gulf.

Related Stories:

5 Reasons There Will Soon Be No More Fish in Our Seas

Success! Super Trawler Banned from Australia’s Oceans

World Ocean Health: A Failing Grade

Photo: Swordfish buoy gear ready for action aboard the F/V Sun Dancer in the northern Gulf of Mexico, August 2012.


Dan Simpson
Dan Simpson5 years ago

why doesn't every country just agree to stop fishing for a whole year to let the oceans recover and reproduce? oh yeah, that's right, human greed has to come first!
if men were meant to fish they'd have tails

Sergio Padilla
Sergio Padilla5 years ago

Thanks for sharing, great news, hope it works!!

Grace Adams
Grace Adams5 years ago

As long as the yellow fin tuna and swordfish targeted by the new gear remain plentiful enough to be fished sustainably, cutting way down on wasteful by-catch is a good idea. What will we do if and when the targeted species decline enough to need protection also?

Tim U.
Tim Upham5 years ago

The Atlantic bluefin tuna has been over harvested, which is the reason why the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) declared it an endangered species. Hopefully, this method of fishing will control the numbers being caught. Another hope is aquaculture, it first stated in Canada, then Australia, and was adopted in the politically unstable North African countries of Tunisia and Libya in the Mediterranean Sea.

Ernest Roth
Ernest R5 years ago

So these improved methods enabling the catching of greater numbers of targeted threatened species will ensure “consumer access to American-caught seafood for decades to come” ? The logic escapes me.

Elsie Au
Elsie Au5 years ago

How about stop eating them.

Marie W.
Marie W5 years ago

We get what we strive for.

Christine Stewart

Good information. We must stop the super-trawlers, the longlines, and the endless gill-nets. Too many animals of non-target species get caught and are drowned/killed before the fishing gear is checked. We must stop the extinction of so many species due to our wasteful fishing methods.

David V.
David V5 years ago

I hope it works..they need to be protected before they disappear from the oceans.

Isabel Araujo
Isabel Araujo5 years ago

I really hope it works! Thank you.