The GOP’s False Promises Emerge as Tax Bill Enters Reconciliation

In a political nail-biter, the GOP finally passed their tax reform bill in the Senate — thanks in large part to a number of late-entrance amendments and lofty promises. But once Vice President Mike Pence provided the tie-breaking vote, the Republican party moved quickly to the next stage: reconciliation.

And that’s when a number of wavering senators learned that the last-minute offers they received in exchange for their votes were about as long-lasting as President Donald Trump’s breaks from Twitter.

It took a variety of sweeteners to finally get skeptical GOP senators on board with the tax reform bill. But the reconciliation process is stripping a number of those amendments out of the final bill, leaving legislators wondering if there was any good faith in the negotiations at all.

Perhaps one of the most frustrated is Maine Senator Susan Collins. In order to get her vote, fellow Republicans included language that would supposedly add money to insurance pools for high-risk insurees still requiring coverage. The assumption was that plan costs would increase dramatically after eliminating the individual mandate requiring all people to have health insurance.

“Collins added two amendments to the legislation that passed the Senate last week, one of which would allow taxpayers to deduct property taxes from their annual federal filings, restoring a provision of the House bill that the Senate took out,” the Hill reported. “Another provision added by Collins would lower the threshold for tax deductions for medical expenses.”

Now, Republican leaders are backtracking on their vow.

“Collins voted for the Senate’s tax reform legislation after Republican leaders, including Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, promised to support legislation to prop up U.S. health insurance markets,” reports Reuters. ”But last week The Hill newspaper reported that House Speaker Paul Ryan told his staff that he wasn’t part of the deal that Collins brokered with Senate leaders.”

And Collins isn’t the only Republican senator to learn that agreements on the Senate floor may be totally disregarded come the committee’s final bill.

Fellow legislators promised Arizona Senator Jeff Flake that the bill wouldn’t stay in effect if it triggered too big of an increase in the national debt. They also assured Flake that the White House would push a legislative answer to reinstating or addressing DACA so that those who were brought into the U.S. illegally as children could remain in the country rather than face deportation.

But Flake voted yes even after the GOP removed the debt trigger –  and Republicans may very well shut down the government rather than allow movement on passing a new DREAM Act.

Of course, GOP senators didn’t just lie to each other — they lied to Americans, too. Besides promising that tax cuts would help the middle class and reduce most people’s taxes, they also claimed that the tax plan wouldn’t affect Medicaid, Social Security or Medicare.

In other words, they lied.

According to the Washington Post:

House Speaker Paul D. Ryan (R-Wis.) said Wednesday that congressional Republicans will aim next year to reduce spending on both federal health care and anti-poverty programs, citing the need to reduce America’s deficit. “We’re going to have to get back next year at entitlement reform, which is how you tackle the debt and the deficit,” Ryan said during an appearance on Ross Kaminsky’s talk radio show. ‘”. Frankly, it’s the health care entitlements that are the big drivers of our debt, so we spend more time on the health care entitlements — because that’s really where the problem lies, fiscally speaking.”

In fact, given the Republican Party’s track record, there’s only one thing you can reliably believe about the GOP: You should never take them at their word.

Photo credit: Caleb Smith/Office of the Speaker, via wikimedia commons

36 comments

Marie W
Marie W8 months ago

thanks for sharing

SEND
Joan E
Joan Eabout a year ago

Gary, you were right, it was Scott Brown that won the special election in MA when Ted Kennedy died. The Democrats were sad to have a Republican win Ted Kennedy's seat when he died, by they agreed to allow Brown to take the seat right away. Now, though, the Republicans don't want to allow Jones to be seated right away the way Brown was. Republicans always look for an unfair advantage instead of doing the right thing. McConnell never does the right thing, always the evil, opportunistic thing.

SEND
Joan E
Joan Eabout a year ago

The repercussions are coming, Republicans, and you're not going to like them.

SEND
Mike Kely
Mike Kabout a year ago

"Republicans Despise the Working Class" - Paul Krugman in today's NY Times.

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/14/opinion/republicans-working-class-taxes.html

SEND
Mike Kely
Mike Kabout a year ago

Here's the petition to goad republican toadies into funding Children's Health Insurance Program

(C.H.I.P.)

http://act.hmpac.com/page/s/Save-Chip?source=MS_EM_PET_2017.12.15_B2_Save-Chip_X__F1_S1_C1__all-ac&email=mikekelly621@gmail.com&zip=%%Zip%%

SEND
Mike Kely
Mike Kabout a year ago

100% of republicans are on board with the "Tax Cuts for Billionaires" bill. Even if your "good" republican voted against the billionaire Christmas present, she or he got permission from the billionaires first.

Republican Senator, Marco Rubio, now says with a straight face that he won't vote for the bill until the deduction for children is increased. Republicans will add another nickel to the deduction and Marco can pretend to be the hero in 2020 when he runs for president of the electoral college again.

Meanwhile, little Marco, hasn't voted to fund C.H.I.P. (Children' Health Insurance Program). 100% of republicans are allowing American Children to lose their health insurance coverage.

Never, ever vote for a republican, in any election, ever.

SEND
Marty P
Marty Pabout a year ago

What A Friggin Dork...Hope He Hits Himself In The Head With That Gavel.

SEND
Elaine W
Elaine Wabout a year ago

If you trust the GOP you are not paying attention.

SEND
Brian F
Brian Fabout a year ago

Their should be a march at the White House demanding the immediate resignation of all these GOP crooks and liars who supported this horrible scam tax bill, and transfer of wealth to the wealthiest people in America. Sneaking this horrible tax bill through in the middle of the night, proves how corrupt the nefarious Republicans are.

SEND
Winn Adams
Winn Aabout a year ago

If their lips are movin, they're lying.

SEND