The UK Gets a Stark Warning About American Meat Imports

The UK is currently embroiled in lengthy negotiations with Europe†regarding†Brexit. Understandably, the UK seeks to make trade deals, now turning its sights to American meat imports.

But food safety and public health watchdogs have†sounded the alarm that any such trade deal shouldn’t erode the UK’s high safety standards. In particular,†many†express concerns about widespread antibiotics use in†animal agriculture.

And if new research is anything to go by, those concerns are well founded.

The U.S. Food Industry Is Using Antibiotics at an Alarming Rate

Campaign group Alliance to Save Our Antibiotics†analyzed recently published data by various regulatory bodies in the UK and the U.S. This data included figures from the UK’s Veterinary Medicines Directorate (VMD) and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). The group also took estimates from†organizations like the British Poultry Council, as well as figures cataloged during cattle farm reviews.

By compiling this data and then making comparisons between the British and the U.S. markets, the Alliance hoped to get a clearer picture of what could happen†if the planned U.S. food trade deal goes ahead after Brexit. More specifically,†the organization†sought to†compare the volume of antibiotics used in the US†to that in the UK — and the findings are stark.

The US uses several times more antibiotics in almost every sector of animal rearing. U.S. pigs†receive nearly double the amount of antibiotics†that UK animals do, while U.S. chickens receive three times more antibiotics than†UK chickens. The highest figure, however, was documented in†cattle. In the U.S., the Alliance estimates that cattle are given anywhere between nine and 16 times the level of antibiotics given to UK cattle.

In terms of average use, the Alliance estimates that all U.S. food animals receive antibiotics in amounts five times greater than in the UK.

Suzi Shingler of the Alliance to Save Our Antibiotics,†explained:

US cattle farmers are massively overusing antibiotics. This finding shows the huge advantages of British beef, which is often from grass-reared animals, whereas US cattle are usually finished in intensive feedlots. Trade negotiators who may be tempted to lift the ban on US beef should not only be considering the impact of growth hormones, but also of antibiotic resistance due to rampant antibiotic use.

When it comes to antibiotics, major UK farming bodies have attempted responsible scale-downs, and they’ve†welcomed outside industry help to accomplish†this goal. The efforts have involved transitioning to large-scale grass-fed operations. While†this solution is by no means perfect for animal welfare,†it provides a more natural setting for cattle and keeps them healthy.

Grass-fed operations are†costly in terms of finance and space, but†they have become†the British standard. Meanwhile, UK farmers say that the U.S.†maintains†vastly different standards, and meat imports risk undermining†welfare and safety regulations, while undercutting British farmers at the expense of both consumer health and animal health.

Antibiotic resistance in action

The U.S. government appears to entirely ignore such concerns, with†Ted McKinney, the Under Secretary for Trade and Foreign Agricultural Affairs at the United States Department of Agriculture†stating†last year during an Oxford Farming Conference, that†“We will hold our food safety, environment and welfare standards up against the UK any day of the week and twice on Sunday,.”

But the data does not lie, and not only does the U.S. overuse antibiotics, its use of†growth hormones†is notorious. Furthermore, British safety groups have serious concerns about U.S. propensity for chlorine-washing chicken carcasses†–††a practice†banned in the EU.

Speaking specifically to the issue of antibiotics use, we have seen in horrifying real-time the effect that mass farming has on impairing our antibiotics. Farms in China and in India have used antibiotics without strict controls, and microbial resistance has grown in areas around those farms.

Bolstering the U.S. market and introducing a new wave of antibiotics-laden meat into the UK has the potential to damage global efforts to reduce antibiotic resistance. Campaigners are calling for trade negotiations to only go ahead if the UK keeps its high standards and does not allow for any compromise on antibiotics overuse. Not only is that important for the farming industry, but it could also be vital to safeguarding long term consumer health.

Photo Credit: Alexander Dimitrov/Unsplash

85 comments

Marie W
Marie W9 days ago

Thank you for posting

SEND
Claire J
Claire Jeffrey4 months ago

Thanks for sharing.

SEND
DAVID fleming
Dave f4 months ago

TY

SEND
Elaine W
Elaine W5 months ago

Not good for people here in the US either. Go vegan.

SEND
Amanda M
Amanda McConnell5 months ago

Thanks for sharing

SEND
Amanda M
Amanda McConnell5 months ago

Thanks for sharing

SEND
Dr. Jan H
Dr. Jan Hill5 months ago

go vegan - live with kindness whenever you can.

SEND
John B
John B5 months ago

Thanks Steve for sharing the info.

SEND
Amanda M
Amanda McConnell5 months ago

i really wish the us would STOP USING ANTIBIOTICS !!!1

SEND
Amanda M
Amanda McConnell5 months ago

Thanks for Sharing

SEND