Thousands of California Doctors Sue Insurance Giant Aetna


Thousands of California doctors have banded together against insurance giant Aetna. The doctors filed a suit against the company in the Los Angeles County Superior Court accusing them of denying patients coverage for out-of-network doctors visits.

The thousands of doctors involved in the suit claim Aetna even refused patients who purchased a policy that allowed them to visit any doctors, whether they were in the network or not.

Reuters reports that the suit was brought by Los Angeles County Medical Association, the California Medical Association, and a variety of health care organizations. The complaint totals 29 pages and was filed on Tuesday, Modern Healthcare reports.

Countering the doctors’ claims, spokespeople for Aetna claim that the new lawsuit is a retaliation to a lawsuit the insurance giant filed against Bay Area Surgical Management in February. In that lawsuit, Aetna charged that most of the doctors overcharged for procedures, in some cases the insurance company claims they overcharged 10 times what they should have for some procedures.

Additionally, Aetna claims that doctores referred patients to out-of-network facilities that were owned by those same medical professionals, thereby gaining a profit without telling their patients.

Reuters quotes an Aetna spokesperson, Cynthia Michener:

We have sued some of these same doctors and surgery centers named in the suit for their egregious billing practices in February of this year…This is a countersuit disguised as a class action lawsuit.

Michener made it clear that Aetna will continue to go after doctors who have accused the company with charges that are “grossly out of line.” MSNBC quotes Michener as saying, “This is a countersuit disguised as a class action suit.” The lawsuit filed by the doctors represents an important stand against the dominance of insurance companies in the medical field. The suit demands compensation for patients and medical professionals in the face of unfair business practices and false advertising.

Actively threatened patients

The newest complaint also asserts that Aetna actively threatened patients with denial of coverage and ejection from the program if they attempted to visit an out-of-network facility.

As Modern Healthcare sums up, the “plaintiffs also seek an order from a judge directing Aetna to cease and desist from discouraging the use of out-of-network providers, and declaring that any Aetna contracts with providers that restrict referrals for out-of-network care are illegal and not enforceable.”

A pitched battle between healthcare providers and insurance giants illustrates the often strained relations between branches of the health care system in the United States. The personal and business interests of companies, both in insurance to pharmaceuticals, continue to plague individuals who have purchased health care but do not receive the coverage they paid for. In this regard the suit these doctors have presented against Aetna has some ground, if they can find and defend the evidence to back up their claims.

Related Stories:

Public Split on Health Care Ruling

US Health Care Reform Efforts Throughout History

Bishops Call for Civil Disobedience Against Health Care Law


Alorha Breaw
Alorha Breaw4 years ago

Is there an update on this?

Edytheortega E.
Past Member 4 years ago

Continue the good work; keep posting more n more n more.

home insurance maryland

Dale Overall

I prefer the Canadian Healthcare system, even if Harper is slowly attempting to get his meat hooks into it he will be tossed out in the next election before he can do real damage. Insurance companies in the U.S. are greedy and the idea that people are not entitled to good health care because they can't afford it is frightening. Everyone should have access to healthcare, it should be a right.

Winn Adams
Winn A5 years ago


june t.
reft h5 years ago

why did it take doctors so long to do something about these blood sucking insurance companies?

Sheri P.
Sheri P5 years ago

insurance providers...grrrr!

Shawn O' Malley
Shawn O' Malley5 years ago

Universal Health Care for all like in "old Europe" where the best quality Healthcare is FREE for everyone. The Consrvatives, Tories in Canada under vulture Harper Corporate rule is destroying decent patient's rights, under the GOP we have "for profit" privatization of healthcare for maximization of CEO benefits and shareholders payouts. Patients only receive the least the Insurance Companies are obliged to pay. Americans are about the worst faring people of the developed world for government protections, economic equality and social justice in the Western world. Wake up and realize this, OCCUPY !!!

Ken W.
Ken W5 years ago

A very good read !

Suzanne H.
Suzanne H5 years ago

Both sides are guilty....Time to change the paradigm.

Terry Vanderbush
Terry V5 years ago

thanks : (