Towns Turn Off the Lights In a Tough Economy (video)

The new year will literally be starting in the dark for the residents of Highland Park in Michigan. With revenues declining for a fifth year in a row, the city’s authorities decided to remove two-thirds of the street lamps. Workers showed up in the fall and took down the poles; the mayor-elect, DeAndre Windom, is advising people to keep their porch lights at night, leading residents to suspect the city is seeking to have them pick up costs it can no longer cover.

Those costs are for something — streetlights — that have been considered as much a part of civic life as sidewalks, crosswalks and traffic lights. That more than a few communities in the US are having to turn out the lights to make ends meet is a sobering reminder of how the economic downturn has altered people’s daily lives. The sight of the familiar streets of your community gone pitch-dark is simply unnerving as we discovered when much of our New Jersey town was dark for a good week after Hurricane Irene. Police cars drove slowly past the eerily quiet storefronts of businesses and streets suddenly unrecognizable in the dark.

Highland Park only has 500 of the 1,600 streetlights it once had. The loss of 600 lights was part of a deal it made with DTE energy, the utility company, to forgive $4 million worth of debt. As the New York Times explains,

The city was paying less than half of its $60,000 monthly bill for an antiquated lighting system that was costly to maintain. So the company and city struck a deal. The company could turn off and take away 1,300 of the city’s lights, add 200 lights in strategic locations, and the debt would be forgiven, said Scott Simons, a spokesman for DTE.

Residents report that they are simply no longer going out at night rather than try to make their way in streets so dark that cars stop just short of pedestrians. Parents fear having children walk to school when it’s still dark in the early morning.

Towns in other states — Oregon, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Illinois, California — have resorted to similar measures, after finding that layoffs, salary cuts and furloughs have not been enough to maintain municipal budgets.

The implicit story in the New York Times‘s account of towns where the lights have been turned off is about the fraying of civic life in a time of economic slowdown and especially in communities that have lost residents, and tax revenues, as factories have closed and employment opportunities have changed. More than 42 percent of Highland Park’s population live in poverty; median income in the town is nearly $30,000 below that of the state. But once it was not so, says the  New York Times, pointing out that Highland Park, site of Henry Ford’s first moving assembly line, was once a well-heeled community with 50,000 residents.

Ford left long ago, and Chrysler’s corporate headquarters moved away in the 1990s. Now it has fewer than 12,000 residents — half the size it was just 20 years ago…

“To understand our street lighting situation is to understand the wealth that Highland Park once had; it was a situation where we had the best of almost everything and an abundance of lights,” said Rodney Patrick, whose father insisted on moving his family to Highland Park in the early 1950s because of its advantages — its status, in his words, as the shining city on the hill. “But we don’t have the residents to have the luxuries we had when we were a city of 50,000.”

Can things have gotten so bad that streetlights have become luxuries in the US?

Mayor-elect Windom says that he has spoken to groups who might consider Highland Park as  the site of a “pilot project for some more energy-efficient, environmentally conscious, experimental lighting system.” It’s regrettable that, in order for the town to progress to a more-up-to date system, it has had to leave so many of its residents in the dark.

Related Care2 Coverage

Whopping Raises for Corporate Execs in 2010

9 Ideas for Congress to Address the 99 Percent

Incomes Even Lower Since Recession Ended


Photo by Ed.ward


KS Goh
KS Goh6 years ago

Thanks for the article.

Nancy Roussy
Nancy Roussy6 years ago

Taking down street lights and asking people to light the front of their homes, what a bunch of pieces of crap! I'm all for saving energy but you can't (well apparently you can!!!!!!!!!) just take away street lights and ask the citizens to light the streets with the lights from their homes!

Debra K.
Debra K6 years ago

It's about time! Why do we need to light up everything all the time? When we as a nation begin to realize that our "clean" electricity is brought to us by the burning of extremely dirty coal maybe more and more towns and business will begin to install either motion sensitive lighting or timer lighting. Not to mention the savings in energy bills. Wow maybe this could start a "movement" to bring down energy costs nationwide which may just help us all out.

Portland N.
P. L. Neola6 years ago

I realize many cities have no choice but to cut down on their utilities. But, it would have been smarter to just take the bulbs out and keep the street lamps!!!

When citizens realize how much crime will increase with the darkness, as well as hit-and-runs, they honestly will be petitioning for their streetlights to be replaced. City officials will end up arranging for some of the lamps to be put back into the ground. Just last Thanks Giving, a young sixteen-year-old-girl—right in front of some of her family members—was rundown in a dark intersection. She is still in critical condition.

Burglaries and rapes will increase in communities. These cities, in the states named above, literally left their residents vulnerable to all sort of crime!!!

Victoria Pitchford
Vicky P6 years ago


Sharon H.
Sharon H6 years ago

@Jutta N...
"I don't know what street lighting have to common with increasing crime."
Try going for a walk on a dark street and see if you're afraid. Criminals don't want lights because they can sneak up on you and if it's dark, you can't identify them.
I think solar lights would be good but they are probably a high cost initially.

Rose Balcom
Rose Balcom6 years ago

Will they roll up the pavement too?

Tyler Hartel
Tyler H6 years ago


KARLOLINA G6 years ago

No if all the big corps would think about this.

Eduardo P.
Eduardo P.6 years ago

Who do you want to petition?
Pres. Obama, US Congress, 50 State’s governor and legislature, GOP presidential candidates, Ministers and parliaments. Gamefowl breeders. Sports and animal lovers. Humane Society of the United States
What do you want to title your petition?
Humane Animal Sport with government / HSUS support can escalate economic and employment growth,
Why should people sign your petition?
Prior to reading below briefs for legal exemption, economic & employment growth, the petition signers are enjoined to view our sport’s package. “The e=roosterbox”: Surf and click video: : The one and only videos will showcase that; ---
“Even the blinds will know they are winning by just counting hit sound; e=roosterbox fights score in the air, mid-air and wrestle in the ground; Like basketball, the fight is improve with visual scoring board, timer and audio. Like boxing the rooster fight can be broadcasted blow by blow…”.
The inventor accede that A USA made prototypes connotes universal security and is sourcing for a US Electronic Companies to exclusively manufacture on the patent life of the invention.
The project challenges Olympic, boxing, taekwondo, martial art couches to train the rooster to be world champion, the rooster fight schedule shall be like UFC, HBO, WBC from Bantamweight to the heavyweight division. Winner of the fight is ranked to qualify for the championship. The fly