Undocumented Teen Suicide Sparks Conservative Backlash

The suicide of an undocumented Texan teen has sparked a backlash from conservatives.

Last month, 18-year-old Joaquin Luna Jr. killed himself and left notes. His family says he had indicated that he was in despair at the failure of the DREAM Act, which would have offered him a path to becoming an engineer. They say that the notes explain the reasons for his despair.

Luna Jr. rang his siblings before he shot himself. He told his half-brother Carlos Mendoza, 29, who lives across the street:

“My road is finished here. I’m going away.”

Mendoza ran to him and broke down a bathroom door, but he was too late.

His mother said he told her:

“I’m never going to be the person I wanted to be. I’m never going to fulfill my dreams.”

The notes were left in a Bible taken by investigators before the family had seen them.

Following the funeral, Rep. Ruben Hinojosa (D-Texas) told Congress that Luna “took his life because he believed that he would never be able to fulfill his dream of becoming an engineer, earning his citizenship and leading a full and prosperous life in America.”

Students at the University of Texas produced t-shirts and posters saying “I am Joaquin.” This echoed a famous Chicano-movement poem of the 1960s.

The Hidalgo County sheriff, Guadalupe Treviño, said that Mr. Luna’s death had been ruled a suicide, but that investigators had not established a motive.

Sheriff Treviño said:

I’m very disappointed that some folks, and even some of our elected leaders, have exploited and politicized this young man’s ill decision to take his own life, especially when we have found no evidence that points to any particular motive.

Nobody knows why he did it. Only he knows for sure why he did what he did.

Americans for Legal Immigration (ALIPAC), called the family’s claim on Luna’s motivation “a hoax by desperate and unscrupulous illegal immigrant invasion supporters.” One ALIPAC administrator, ‘Jean,’ wrote of Luna Jr.’s death:

“The latest pro-amnesty salvo comes in the form of an act of cowardice … The boy made a bigger mistake when he chose suicide over hard work.”

Right-wing website Newsbusters claimed that ‘CNN Helps Politicize Tragic Teen ‘Dream Act Suicide.”

ALIPAC cited an investigator who told a local news station before they were released to the family that the bible notes did not mention either the DREAM Act or Luna Jr.’s undocumented status. But half-brother Diyer Mendoza says he was told of the letters contents by the investigation in the days after the suicide and says:

I know he did it because of his legal status. I lived with him; I shared time with him. I know what I know.

The letters have now been released to the family and one note, which the sheriff’s office made public, does say:

I have realized that I have no chance in becoming a civil engineer the way I have always dreamed of here.

Says Diyer Mendoza:

Every time he would put in an application, the first thing that would pop up was ‘Are you a U.S. citizen?’ No. ‘Resident?’ No. ‘Social Security number?’ No. It was all just mounting and mounting on top of him. I truly believe that if that Dream Act would have already passed, he would still be here today.

Richard Hartwell, founder of the web site Action Dream Team, which provides a forum for ‘Dreamers’, said Luna’s fears of failing have much merit.

“I can show you people that have multiple degrees in science that are working as interpreters because they can’t work in their field because they don’t have nine numbers,” Harwell said.

By not passing the DREAM Act, Hartwell said the government is pushing talent and an economic boost elsewhere.

“Many of these young people are actually going to Canada, where with a degree and a job offer, Canada will welcome you,” Hartwell said.

Marie-Theresa Hernández wrote on Dream Act Texas:

“How many DREAMers see things like the sign proudly displayed at the front door of the Soup Plantation near Upland California that says “WE USE E-VERIFY” (in other words we call ICE on undocumented immigrants) – or the video showing Congressman Mo Brooks from Alabama saying he will do everything but shoot undocumented immigrants. What can these terrible things do to a young impressionable mind?”

The DREAM Act was blocked in the Senate in 2010 despite having a majority.

Homeland Security Department recently issued a memo saying that those who would have qualified for the DREAM Act should be low on the priority list for deportation. It also listed other factors, such as caring for a family, that would lower the risk of deportation.

However, Syracuse University’s Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse (TRAC) says that despite a supposed focus on deporting criminals, most of those targeted by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) are not criminals.

Related stories:

Undocumented Texan Teen Kills Self

Republican Group Admits We Need Immigration Reform

Hate Crimes Against Latinos Spike

Picture by Korean Resource Center


Christopher M.
Christopher M.6 years ago

The Other R starts out correct.

Marjorie L., the majority of North Americans have decided to control the population and protect shared resources for the future. Witness our birth rates. There is no excuse for treating the US like a dumping ground for the world's poor and dispossessed. No reason to accept the overflow from cultures that can't stop breeding.

What is the United States? The social safety net for the world's people who keep on breeding and don't save and limit their numbers responsibly? Maybe if it is, we should be first in line.

Christopher M.
Christopher M.6 years ago

We have endless numbers of teenagers who are citizens who need admission to college and scholarships. Why are we dealing with endless numbers of immigrants instead?

Sorry but we cannot educate the entire hemisphere for free.

Sarah Metcalf
Sarah M6 years ago

This is utterly heartbreaking and it really infuriates me that people can be so ignorant and full of hatred. What conservatives stand for makes me sick to the core--they are heartless fiends.

Darlene B.
Darlene W6 years ago

Bless all involved. It is a sad situation-this issue has been a problem for years and needs to be dealt with. Why is it always put on the back burner? Regardless, this young man had no answers. If there were laws to address this, it probably would not have happened. Wake up Congress and those who run this country--DO YOUR JOB!!

Norma V.
Norma Villarreal6 years ago

Prayers go out to the family...

Marianna B M.

very sad

Chad A.
Chad A6 years ago

The problem with nations and borders is that there are just that many more reasons and excuses for us to come up with to hate, marginalize, and isolate. When times are tough it is easy enough to demonize others and blame them for our problems. Why is it that the usual targets are the most powerless?

Alicia N.
Alicia N6 years ago

so sadly noted....

Lynn C.
Lynn C6 years ago

Why add to what's been expressed ad nauseam. No comment.

Mercedes Lackey
Mercedes Lackey6 years ago

Let's just put one lie completely to rest.

Alabama created the most draconian (for you people who don't understand big words, that means "really out of control') anti-immigration laws in the country.

Now crops are rotting in the fields, people can't find roof repairmen, and hundreds if not thousands of other jobs are going undone because the undocumented--and sometimes legal citizens!--workers have fled Alabama.

No US citizen is stepping up to take those jobs. Evidently no US citizen wants them, not at that pay, not at that hazard.

So. "Illegal immigrants" are doing the work not even the most desperate US citizen will do. They are NOT taking jobs that anyone else wants.

Proven, in Alabama. Fact.

Case closed.