UVA Student’s Murder Shows Need for New Awareness About Dating Violence

As a college student and a Charlottesville native, I was doubly horrified by the news of the murder of Yeardley Love, which my mother, a University of Virginia professor, emailed to me a few days ago.  The details of Love’s death emerged on Tuesday, and have sparked a new dialogue about alcohol abuse and relationship violence on campuses where students neglect to take these issues seriously.  Yeardley Love was a senior and a lacrosse player at UVA; her suspected killer is another lacrosse player and her ex-boyfriend, a senior named George Huguely.  According to friends, she had ended the months-long relationship fairly recently.  The investigation is ongoing, but I’ve included many of the details that have been released.

The details of Love’s murder are chilling.  According to police documents, Huguely admitted to breaking into Love’s room by kicking down the door; he then attacked Love, swinging her by the neck and shaking her, causing her head to hit the wall repeatedly.  He then left her facedown in her bed, taking her computer with him.  When Love’s body was found, she had a bruised face, a swollen eye, and scrapes on her chin.

According to police reports, Huguely has a known problem with violence and alcohol; in 2008, he was involved in an altercation with a female police officer in Lexington, VA.  After the officer asked an intoxicated Huguely whether anyone could pick him up so that he could avoid having to go to jail, he released a diatribe of racist and sexual insults.  He then became combative, fighting with the officer until she was forced to taser him.  The next day, he remembered almost nothing of the incident.

In the wake of the accident, UVA President John Casteen told students that they should be “outraged” at Love’s death.  He encouraged students to seek out help for violent relationships, a refrain that has been much repeated in the past few days.  Mary Beth Lineberry, the website managing editor of the UVA Women’s Center writes, “Love’s death exposes an unfortunate reality of college life that’s often obscured or silenced in communities…students generally don’t think the statistics [about dating violence] apply to them.”  She quotes Claire Kaplan, the director of Sexual and Domestic Violence Services at the Women’s Center, who explained,  “The perception often among students is that such violence exists only for unhappy married couples.  In reality, IPV affects all types of relationships and all backgrounds and personalities of people.”

The cultural silence surrounding partner abuse and dating violence of which Lineberry speaks is something that I know exists on my own campus as well.  During my freshman year, another student was arrested for kidnapping his girlfriend and holding her against her will in his dorm.  I’m not sure how the case progressed, but it certainly demonstrates the way we stop talking about these issues immediately afterward, and how quickly they leave institutional memory.

People have questioned whether the UVA athletics department should have done more to discipline Huguely for his violent episodes; Lee Carpenter, a Yahoo News sportswriter, writes that “Information on athletes’ misdeeds, especially in non-revenue sports, is rarely gathered. And even when it is collected, the facts are often tucked away in hopes no one will notice. College presidents hire coaches who constantly make poor decisions in the name of winning.”

But I think this is part of a larger problem than the UVA athletics department.  College women are not empowered to recognize or leave abusive relationships, and when they try, they don’t know how to ask for the kinds of resources that could have saved Love’s life.  And the administration doesn’t promote an open or honest conversation about what this kind of violence actually looks like.  Part of the problem is exemplified by the email sent to the student body by UVA Chief Mike Gibson, who tells students to “keep your doors and windows locked” and “never allow strangers to follow you into a locked building.”  Which is clearly not the issue here – Huguely kicked Love’s door open, and he was decidedly not a stranger to the campus community, so neither of these warnings apply.  Instead, they make it seem as though the problem comes from outside the campus, rather than inside it.  This kind of violence can happen to anyone, anywhere – and people need to know how to recognize abuse and seek help.

The university’s responsibility in the wake of this horrible crime is to educate its students about partner abuse – not some vaguely defined stranger danger.  It’s much scarier to imagine that the violence could come from within a community, but the truth is that locks are not a defense against an abusive boyfriend.  And the university owes it to its students to recognize that fact honestly.

Photos from Wikimedia Commons.


Beverly C.
Beverly C7 years ago

As a 61 year old female retired high school teacher, I don't blame it all on the fathers and peer pressure, but macho Dads who talk big and are disrespectful toward women, including their sons' mother, I have witnessed to be a recipe for violence fostered by feelings of entitlement. Also, the "group mentality", in which a group of people will many times commit acts which one lone person, with no peer support or prodding, would not commit. --There, certainly, are many mean girls, though boys usually have the physical strength to overpower their partners, dates, etc. Unfortunately, hot-shot big-talking boastful fathers are no help in disciplining or even working with their sons regarding respecting their female partners, friends, fellow-students, co-workers, etc.. --Domestic violence and partner abuse are very dangerous and often lethal situations. --People in these situations need to run and not look back. --If the person who is being abused fears that the abuser will follow them and hurt or kill them, they need to take refuge at a shelter for epole fleeing from abuse.

Janice P.
Janice P7 years ago

Dating violence has always been a problem, although it seems to have greatly escalated in the past 50 years. Although I do not ever blame everything on the parents, there is much truth to what Pamela had to say. From where are these men getting the idea that they have the right to lay a a hand on anyone? Who has taught them any different? If no one, why not?

Abo Ahmed r.
Abo r7 years ago

No violence of any kind,safety and peace for all

Morgan G.
Morgan Getham7 years ago

As someone who has served in an administrative capacity in the mental health field, I can assure you that domestic violence is NOT entirely gender specific. Although abuse of women is by far the more common, abuse of males by females is not unknown. And however it happens, it needs to be prevented. It is a serious problem.

It is NOT, as one earlier person suggested, a "testosterone" problem. That is just some sexist thinking gotten out of hand. It is a problem of propensity to violence, which can occur in anyone prone to it regardless of gender.

The best piece of advice is, stay as far away from violent individuals as possible. This man had a history of violent behavior. As the article points out, people need to understand that the statistics about death and injury are NOT abstracts that happen to other people. Get involved with someone who is violent, and they can happen to YOU, regardless of who you are or who your partner is.

johan l.
paul l7 years ago

What about the poor girl's family!
To reprimand sportsstars for their behaviour, is clearly not the answer!
If you are violent, you are violent!
No number of admonishments are going to change you.
The UVA and all other universities should try and work out what more they can do to protect girl students.
As for the Chief Mike Gibson, he clearly has no clue what he is talking about.
Time to get another one!

Alicia Nuszloch
Alicia N7 years ago

I am very sorry for the girl's death. R I P .

Heidi C.
Heidi L7 years ago

Very sad

Helen Snyder
Helen Snyder7 years ago

hmmmm .. just wondering .. would it do any good to test testosterone levels and is there any way to lower them ?? There seems to be physical compenemt to this "male rage" as well as the "macho attitude" .. we raise them, ladies .. and by our silence we enable this behaviour.

Judeth B.
judeth B7 years ago

Why do a lot of men think that a woman has to do as he wishes?

Sheila L.
sheila l7 years ago

sad situation