Victory! Judge Throws Out Arizona Planned Parenthood Law

A federal judge last Friday overturned HB 2800, a state law in Arizona that banned Planned Parenthood from contracting with Medicaid.

From The New American:

In his 11-page ruling shooting down the measure duly passed by the state’s elected lawmakers, federal Judge Neil Wake said that there was no reason to believe the abortion giant was not qualified to provide non-abortion “family planning” services covered under the federal medical assistance program, and that the law appeared to be an attempt by Arizona legislators to disqualify Planned Parenthood from state and federal funding.

Anti-abortion advoate Governor Jan Brewer had signed this bill, misleadingly called “The Whole Woman’s Health Funding Priority Act,” into law last May, thereby blocking Medicaid family planning funds from flowing to any health organization that provided abortions. It effectively prevented thousands of low-income Medicaid recipients in Arizona from choosing Planned Parenthood as a health and family planning provider.

Despite the fact that the use of public funds for abortions was already restricted, this particular funding was intended to ban prohibited money from going to any health care providers that provided abortions at all.

Of course, making health care services inaccessible doesn’t make the need for those services go away. What it does mean is that women have to go to greater expense simply to take care of their bodies. And if it costs too much, women will choose to skip doctors’ appointments.

During a signing ceremony Governor Brewer called the measure a “common-sense law that tightens existing state regulations and closes loopholes in order to ensure that taxpayer dollars are not used to fund abortions, whether directly or indirectly. By signing this measure into law, I stand with the majority of Americans who oppose the use of taxpayer funds for abortion.”

But not everyone agreed with Brewer. Planned Parenthood has fought back in every state that has removed its funding, pointing out that this is an assault on all women making their own decisions about their bodies, and particularly an assault on poor women.

The state of Indiana has also been able to stop the defunding of Planned Parenthood, but not so in Texas. As The Washington Post points out, the big difference between the two cases is that Indiana wanted to continue using federal dollars for its program.

From The Washington Post:

These two rulings, taken together, suggest states have a pretty stark choice if they want to defund Planned Parenthood. They can ditch federal funding and, under the Fifth Circuit’s interpretation, move forward. But if they want to continue using Medicaid dollars, as Indiana has done, the court system looks to be less amenable to such a program.

And if you thought women sent a strong signal during the election that they disagreed with the war on women, apparently not everyone heard them: just a few weeks into this new Congress, there are already not one, but two, bills that attempt to defund Planned Parenthood. Tennessee Representatives Marsha Blackburn and Diane Black have both introduced bills that would prohibit family planning grants from going to organizations that provide abortions.

The war on women is still raging, but Planned Parenthood’s success in Arizona shows that we are still ready to fight.

Thanks for fighting against the war on women in Arizona by signing these important petitions!


Related Care2 Coverage

Arizona De-Funds Planned Parenthood

Arizona Students Must Swear Loyalty To God In Order To Graduate

Kansas Drops Charges Against Planned Parenthood

Photo Credit: Donkey Hotey


Cathleen K.
Cathleen K4 years ago

Good news. Jan Brewer is proof that abortion should be legal. How much better off the world would be if her mother had had one. All of the states that have pushed these bans have also instituted 'stand your ground' laws, and the few beleaguered clinics remaining are under constant assault from anti choice protesters. I sometimes truly regret the pacifistic, factual debate orientation of the left, because they'll never avail themselves of the license to kill these vicious idiots that 'stand your ground' affords them.

Duane B.
.4 years ago

Thank you for sharing.

Eternal Gardener
Eternal Gardener4 years ago


Pat Patton
Pat Patton4 years ago

Pamela W., If you look at the link I provided you will see why I wrote, "I regret my abortion."

If you need me to explain further I'm glad to do so - just let me know.

my best to you, Pat

Pamela W.
Pamela W4 years ago

Pat Patton Pat P.
12:54PM PDT on Mar 19, 2013

I regret my abortion:

Backtracking Pat ? You posted this information / confession THREE TIMES !!!!

Pat Patton
Pat Patton4 years ago

Ladies, if anybody tries to sell you on the idea that the pro-life movement has to be rooted in a religious basis then I have news for them.

Check out this organization:

And so I'd be curious as to what atheists and agnostics here have to say to their fellow atheists and agnostics who fight for life!


Pat Patton
Pat Patton4 years ago

I've never had an abortion. But these women did and they regretted it. So before any woman has one I encourage you to listen to these ladies and consider their words carefully. Listen to the other side too.

Which side will you fall on?

I regret my abortion:

John Hablinski
John Hablinski4 years ago

Pat, no one has disputed the idea that some women who have had abortions have regrets later. It is a human trait to ponder the road not traveled. The same can be truthfully said about women who married. That doesn’t mean we should ban marriage.

Robynne W.
Robynne W4 years ago

Yes Pat, I believe you do regret having your abortion.

Pat Patton
Pat Patton4 years ago

I regret my abortion: