Why Are We Still Being Deceived by Egg Labels?

Every year, hundreds of millions of egg-laying hens are forced to spend their lives in cages so small they can’t move, while producers continue to dupe consumers into believing they’re making compassionate choices with misleading labels and getting them to pay more for products they believe are humane.

Last week, the Animal Legal Defense Fund (ALDF) and Compassion Over Killing (COK) filed a complaint in a federal district court in Oakland against the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) and Agriculture Marketing Service, and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) for failing to regulate animal welfare labeling on egg cartons.

Despite previous petitions requesting that production methods be listed on egg cartons, no action has been taken by the government and consumers continue to be misled about the level of care that egg-laying hens receive.

“Labeling requirements would help consumers avoid purchasing eggs from mistreated hens,” said ALDF executive director Stephen Wells. “It is long past due for these agencies to regulate the rampant false and misleading labeling used by egg producers to sell cruelly-produced food to well-intentioned shoppers.”

The groups are now requesting that egg producers nationwide would be required to clearly label egg cartons with egg production methods, including the identification of “Eggs from Caged Hens,” according to the ALDF.

But are eggs from cage-free, free-range or organic farms really any better?

These labels seem to conjure up images of hens living in environments where they can enjoy a range of natural behaviors, such as nesting and dust bathing. However, there are no regulations when it comes to the cage-free label. These hens can still spend their entire lives in overcrowded barns or warehouses, without ever seeing the sun or getting fresh air. ‘Free-range’ hens are uncaged inside, usually without access to the outdoors. There are no regulations about how much outdoor access they should have. Whether they actually get any or not is another story.

Regardless of the type of farm, egg production involves a number of unfortunate practices that are considered standard by the egg industry, including the mass killing of male chicks, who are typically thrown into grinders while they’re still alive or suffocated, debeaking, forced molting, which involves keeping hens in complete darkness and starving them for about two weeks to trick their bodies into another egg-laying cycle, and finally sending hens who are no longer producing at a profitable rate to slaughter, which will usually happen before they’re two-years-old — a fraction of their normal lifespan.

If making compassionate and ethical food choices is a priority, the only way to seriously support the end of suffering inflicted on animals used in agriculture is to pass on animal products.



Related Stories:

Behind the “Cage-Free” Label

Chickens Feel Empathy, Why Can’t We?

4 Questions to Ask Your Egg Farmer


Photo credit: Thinkstock


michael g o'leary
michael o'leary4 years ago

i am always willing to pay more for eggs from free range hens. hens don't deserve to have to live caged to lay eggs, they end up being sick and under a terrible amount of stress and anxiety and all that leads to an early death

Grainne O'Carroll
Grainne OCarroll4 years ago

I only ever bought free range organic eggs, but became completely vegan when I discovered they kill off the male chicks (sometimes in terribly cruel ways). Ditto for male calves.

Carrie-Anne Brown

thanks for sharing

.4 years ago

thank you for sharing

Waheeda S.
Waheeda E4 years ago

I hope the ALDF makes some headway against these greedy and cruel corporations!

Amy L.
Amy L4 years ago

I'm sick and tired of the these companies tricking the average person. I buy eggs but always buy organic, cage free thinking that these babies are outdoors pecking around. How do you know whose lying and whose not. I don't want to contribute in anyway to the torture of any animal or eat animal products raised inhumanely. Vegan is looking more and more tempting everyday.

Kerstin S.
Kerstin S4 years ago

I get my eggs from organic farms

Margarita G.
Margarita G4 years ago

Thanks for posting!

Alicia Lopez
Alicia Lopez4 years ago

yes, I eat eggs, yes I eat meat and can't stand to watch these videos...but how else are we supposed to get the real impact of what's going on behind closed doors. Or better yet, these are not even behind closed doors but going out in the open as I'm typing this comment. This is so inhumane and beyond belief that we humans can't think of a better way? Let's put our brains to better use and apply it to help our fellow animals. Yes, we consume them but at least treat them better while they are still alive. We can't ask them questions, but you can see that they are hurting mentally and physically.

Pamela Tracy
Pamela Tracy4 years ago

I started not liking the taste of eggs...I was born and raised in Montana and our family bought mostly local eggs.....and Montana i will look into these places that are selling us eggs....I am sick at how we live. You are right....all the eggs should be destroyed before they get to market...can you imagine what we are eating....