Why Republicans Should Just Stop Talking About Homosexuality

Wisconsin is moving forward when it comes to equal rights regardless of sexual orientation, becoming the latest state to start offering marriage licenses to same-sex partners. Sadly, even as more states continue to recognize that homosexuality is not a choice, a disease or a deviation, we still see people fighting against the changing tide. The recent drafting of the Republican party platform in Texas, which demanded a return to the “option” of discredited reparative therapy as a means of converting someone away from their sexual attraction to members of the same sex, shows a GOP determined to hold onto every last shred of homophobia it can grasp. To do so, they are demanding that the politicians in their party do the same.

Every time they talk about it, frankly, it just gets worse. Just this week Texas Governor Rick Perry, who is expected to toss his hat into the ring for the 2016 Republican presidential nomination, once more reminded us how deeply engrained his party’s homophobia is. At a political event in California, Gov. Perry was asked whether he believed that homosexuality is a “disorder,” and his answer was that in fact it was more like a disease.

“Whether or not you feel compelled to follow a particular lifestyle or not, you have the ability to decide not to do that,” Perry said, according to SF Gate. “I may have the genetic coding that I’m inclined to be an alcoholic, but I have the desire not to do that, and I look at the homosexual issue the same way.”

Gov. Perry is by no means the first conservative to compared being gay to being an alcoholic. Ken Buck did the same in his Colorado senate run in  2010, and lost to Democrat Michael Bennett in what was otherwise a Republican sweep year. What’s really interesting in the “alcoholic” language is that it takes the small step of acknowledging biological factors, but then alludes to it as not only a sickness, but something that although it cannot be removed, can be ignored through will and some sort of strength of character, like being an alcoholic is addressed by simply being strong enough to not ever take that drink.

If Gov. Perry’s assertions on homosexuality sound antiquated, though, it’s not nearly as old-fashioned as those of an Oklahoma candidate for the state legislature, whose opinions are downright biblical. According to Death and Taxes’s Robyn Pennacchia, Republican candidate Scott Esk said he wouldn’t be opposed to bringing back stoning to death of homosexuals, at least, not if it were someone else’s idea.

“I think we would be totally right to do it,” Esk told a local publication. ”That goes against some parts of libertarianism, I realize, and I’m largely libertarian, but ignoring as a nation things that are worthy of death is very remiss.” When asked if he really, really meant it was a good idea to kill those who were gay, he asserted, “I never said I would author legislation to put homosexuals to death, but I didn’t have a problem with it.”

Given yet another chance to clarify his views, Esk still didn’t change his tune. “What I will tell you right now is that was done in the old testament under a law that came directly from God. And in that time, it was totally just, it came directly from God. I have no plans to, you know, reinstitute that in Oklahoma law. I do have some very huge moral misgivings about those kinds of sins.”

Despite being given ample opportunities to prove otherwise, the more they are asked about equal rights for the LGBT community, the more Republican politicians continue to assert that homosexuality is at best a sickness that should be fought and at worst a grave sin that one should be executed over.

If this week has shown us nothing else, it has shown us that maybe, just maybe, when it comes to public policy surrounding gays, the Republican party should just stop talking.

Photo credti: Thinkstock


donald Baumgartner

" Live & Let Live !!" " What will be will be"!!!!

Donna F.
Donna F3 years ago


Janis K.
Janis K3 years ago

Thanks for sharing.

Dale O.

Republicans should simply just hide under the dark rock from where it emerged and never be seen or heard from again. Certainly, they tend to avoid embracing any form of progressive or enlightened thought. Republicans such as Governor Rick Perry embrace intolerance and prejudice as their daily bread.

The idea of the Texas GOP embracing reparative therapy is unnerving, but then, so is the GOP as a whole.

Ashley heffner
Lady Suki3 years ago

I agree with Joel.

Ashley heffner
Lady Suki3 years ago

As a Liberal, I am horrified by statements like Rick Perry's comparing homosexuality to being an alcoholic. On the other hand, I know that such statements drive people away from the G.O.P.

In addition to this, is it better to not know when people hold these beliefs? At least if they are honest about their feelings, we can respond appropriately. They are never going to learn that treating LGBT people like second class citizens is unacceptable, if they don't open their big fat mouths first. Then we attempt to educate them. If that fails, they can take their place in history next to those that were against interracial marriage.

Joel Hunt
Joel Hunt3 years ago

Surely they need to talk about it as often as they can? Otherwise people like this can slide into power without anyone realising that they are ok with small matters such as stoning people to death.

Just think of Hitler; yes he was open about his hatred for Jews, but he never actually ran on a platform of genocide. That part was secret, it wasn't talked about in the open, even when most people knew about it. If he had stood up in 1933 and said "I think we should literally kill every single Jew", then he'd basically have locked himself out of office.

These people need to speak loudly and honestly so that we know exactly how far they would be willing to go, and can react to that accordingly.

Candy Carr
Candy Carr3 years ago

Thnk u for posting

Rosa Caldwell
Rosa Caldwell3 years ago

It needs to be talked about in order to educate. How else will we learn.

Winn Adams
Winn A3 years ago

Republicans and Tea Baggers should just stop talking period, end of discussion.