Would You Eat Shmeat?


Shmeat refers to a “sheet of lab-grown” meat. To make it, tissue engineers take stem cells from animals and place them in a nutrient-rich culture that, previously, had to be made from substances from animals, such as blood. But scientists have developed a non-animal nutrient option that, like photo synthesis, uses sunlight and carbon dioxide to grow the tissue. So far, says Mother Jones, they’ve only been able to grow meat cells 2.5 centimeters long and 0.7 centimeters wide. A recent report estimated that the world’s first in vitro burger could cost a half a million dollars, a far cry from the items on McDonald’s dollar menu.

Scientists met last week in a workshop in Gothenburg, Sweden, about what needs to be done to make manufacturing shmeat viable. I’ve been a vegetarian for the past 30 years and personally am not interesting in eating even a sliver of shmeat (or of any sort of meat, in general). But, as Mother Jones notes, with the world population continuing to grow, and per capita meat consumption (especially in China) grows along with it, lab-grown meat could be a viable option. The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations predicts that meat consumption will double between 2000 and 2050.

Even more, lab-grown meat also holds some real benefits for the environment:

We wouldn’t need to use as much land for agriculture (both for raising livestock and for growing their feed). We wouldn’t have to use all the water that meat production requires, or the pesticides, hormones, or other problematic additives so common in industrial agriculture.

Indeed, a recent study from Oxford University and the University of Amsterdam found that, when compared to regular beef, synthetic meat would:

  • Use 45 percent less energy overall
  • Create 96 percent less greenhouse gas emissions
  • Require 99 percent less land
  • Use 96 percent less water

And we could reduce the threat of animal-to-human diseases, like bird flu, E. coli, and salmonella. It would also be possible to control things like the fat, cholesterol, or calorie content of a synthetic-meat product.

PETA is offering a $1 million reward for whoever can both create in vitro chicken, and make it commercially viable, by June 30, 2012 — in less than a year. The contest has been going on for three years and has stoked disputes within PETA. Is it all right to eat meat if it is created in vitro rather than by slaughtering animals? Or would it be better for people just to not eat meat at all?

Mother Jones notes that the real challenge for those environmental scientists, ethicists, social scientists and economists who are trying to produce “Franken-meat” and to make it economically feasible is, perhaps, a more basic, less philosophical, concern. There’s still an ingrained “yuck” factor about eating what is, indeed, ersatz meat; about chowing down on what could more properly be dubbed “meat product.” Researchers say they need more funding to continue their efforts to develop lab-grown meat. Might those funds be rather, or even better, used to encourage people to learn how to eat and live without meat?


Related Care2 Coverage

Eat Less Meat to Fight Climate Change

Could Eating Bugs Help Slow Climate Change?

Yummy! Some Pink Slime in That Burger?


Photo by Nina Pope


Jim Ven
Jim Venabout a year ago

thanks for sharing.

Christine Jones
Christine J2 years ago

Sure, why not? Personally I'd rather have a nice potato or carrot, but to each their own. If it can prevent factory farming of animals, go for it. The name's clever too.

Ray C.
Ray C3 years ago

I don't believe any meat is safe to eat due to BSE

Kate R.
Past Member 3 years ago

Sure, why not?

Yvonne Wey
Yvonne Wey3 years ago

No thanks think I stay with tofu

Duane B.
.5 years ago

Thank you for sharing.

Karen B.
Past Member 5 years ago

I would try shmeat, as long as it is healthy.
I prefer that to the bloody meat industry.
I'm vegan, not because I don't like meat but because I cannot
be part of the horrific suffering of sentinent beings , all for a
product we do not need!

Rosa mc
Lydia Mcintyre5 years ago

Gross! I would never eat shmeat or meat!

Karen C.
Karen C5 years ago

I would not eat shmeat and I want the option to choose so do not sneak it in to food without labeling it!

The increase of lab made food products is helping to cause the demise of the human race. While the the planet may be better off, what difference will it make there are no human beings left. The money would be better spent teaching people to eat less meat and to only eat meat that is ethically raised.

Sandra Streifel
Sandra S5 years ago

Sure, I think shmeat would be great! It would be ground-up texture at first, but soon it would be possible to make it in all kinds of different steak, fish fillet, etc. forms. I should think.