Greener Dishwasher Detergents

by Cris Carl, Networx

A walk down the dish product aisle in most anyone’s local supermarket will turn up an almost surprising bevy of new cleaning products. The common denominator companies are reaching for in many products is low or no phosphates. Phosphates have been the primary cleaning agent in dishwasher and laundry soaps for a long time. As of July 1, 2010, 16 states have banned phosphate content in cleaning products to 0.5 percent. Up until now, companies could get away with content up to 8.7 percent. Low phosphate dishwasher detergent, while better for the environment, has proven to be lackluster in many cases in its ability to clean. Here is some overall information about low-phosphate cleaning products and how they work in dishwashers.

First of all, why are phosphates in dishwashing detergents being banned?

Phosphates are noted to cause an increase in algae bloom as well as other aquatic plant life. More algae equals less oxygen for other aquatic life, i.e. fish. In other words, your spotless glasses can be a contributor to the death of rivers and streams.

While statistically, most phosphates that leak into our rivers and streams come from urban and agricultural sources (such as animal waste and fertilizers), Americans add a significant phosphate load from dishwashing detergents. Sewage treatment plants and private septic systems are able to remove some of the phosphates, but not all. With bans on phosphates spreading across the country, companies have begun reformulating their products at a fast pace. There are no bans on commercial dishwashing products. However, most professional dishwashers use high temperatures (160 degrees) to clean and sterilize dishware.

Next: Which low or no-phosphate dishwasher detergents are the best?

Which low or no-phosphate dishwasher detergents are the best?

The most reliable study on this topic was done by Consumer Reports following the announcement of the bans on phosphates in dishwashing detergent. Twenty-four low to no phosphate dishwasher detergent products were tested.

The top products in their tests came in the form of tables and pacs. Gels tested the lowest in cleaning ability. Top brands included several produced by Finish (previously known as Electrosol), Cascade Complete, and Cascade Dawn Action Pacs.  Numerous low to no phosphate products have been on the market for years produced by “green” companies such as Seventh Generation. Citradish Automatic Dish Detergent and BioKleen Free and Clean Automatic Dish Powder also did well in tests.

Are low to no phosphate dishwasher detergents compatible with most dishwashers?

Low to no phosphate dishwashing detergents do not harm dishwashers, and nearly all will work relatively well with low to no phosphate dishwashing detergent. Newer dishwashing machines with expanded technology will likely work the best to clean your dishes. Some dishwashers on the market now for example “sense” how dirty the dishes are and adjust the power of the water spray accordingly.

If you experience a film or clouding on your glasses, that can be caused by the alkalinity of the water (not the type of detergent). Glass exposed to high alkaline aqueous solution will essentially melt the glass over time. “Etching” of glass happens in a similar fashion when flaws in the dishware are exposed as the glass (very) gradually melts.

States that have banned phosphates:

Illinois, Indiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Montana, New Hampshire, Vermont, Ohio, Oregon, Virginia, Pennsylvania, Washington, Utah, and Wisconsin.

Are Green Cleaning Products Really Safe?
Guide to Cleaning Product Labels
Make Your Own Eco-Friendly Dishwasher Detergent
Clean Your Plate: Energy-Saving Dishwashing Tips


Diane L.
Diane L4 years ago

Mary Beth, would it be safe to say you don't like P&G? Maybe those that buy their products buy them because they work. I use TIDE and that's all I wlll buy as it does the best job and ends up being the most economical product. To each, their own.

Mary Beth M.
MaryBeth M4 years ago

Something to consider: Cascade, owned by the mega-giant Proctor & Gamble, has an abysmal record in regards to animal abuse. Proctor & Gamble continues to test on animals, has outsourced to China, where incredibly cruel animal testing is mandatory, and has no plans to change its practices. Unfortunately, P & G is unmoved by petitions, letters, requests for stopping these cruel and unnecessary forms of animal cruelty, as they have a huge market share. Just glance in shopping baskets or ask friends or neighbors which products they use. Some examples: Tide, Crest, Cascade, Old Spice, among many others. P&G has little motive to change. People buy their products regardless of their cruelty and avarice.

Winn Adams
Winn A5 years ago


Ermes B.
Ermes B5 years ago


J.L. A.
JL A5 years ago

phosphate-free laundry has been possible since the 1970's...

Patricia H.
Patricia H.5 years ago

thanks for sharing

Michele Wilkinson

Thank you

Nancy Sasko
Nancy Sasko7 years ago

Thank you

Priscilla G.
Priscilla G7 years ago

Thankyou for the info.

Darla G.
Darla G.7 years ago

I have had issues with most dishwasher detergents since moving to our house 10 years ago. Tried eco-friendly, homemade non-toxic and even commercial "bad" brands. None seem to work or work for long. Last week, had washed a load of only glassware that had all been prerinsed and they came out looking like I soaked them in oatmeal... eeeewwww....Had a chat with my appliance repairman and he even checked all teh filters adn tehy were clean....and he said that these new dishwashers need water at a min 120 degrees to make the machines work and properly disolve the soaps regardless of what kind. As well, prerinsing only leaves the soap with nothing to do, leaving a soap build up in the dishwasher. just a little food for thought.