How Safe is Raw Milk?

Lately there has been some controversy brewing over milk–specifically raw milk, and its sale and safety. By definition, raw milk is milk that has not been pasteurized or homogenized. Proponents of the raw stuff insist it not only tastes better, but it’s also more nutritious since it hasn’t been heated to kill off pathogens. So why is it so objectionable to public health officials?

According to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), raw milk can harbor dangerous microorganisms that pose serious health risks, mainly foodborne illnesses spawned mostly from bacteria like Salmonella, E. coli, and Listeria. The FDA further claims that pasteurization, a heating process developed back in 1864, does not cause lactose intolerance or allergic reactions, nor does it reduce milk’s nutritional value.
But raw milk enthusiasts tell a different tale, insisting that their preferred beverage is actually safer than pasteurized milk because it is gleaned from healthy, grass-fed cows, which also may account for the difference in taste. Conventionally raised cows, advocates argue, need their milk to be pasteurized because they live on bacteria-prone industrial farms. Grass-fed cows do not reside in such dangerous conditions, and therefore their milk might actually be less likely to cause illness.

And according to data released by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) earlier this year, nearly half of foodborne illnesses in the United States from 1998 to 2008 were linked to fruits, nuts, leafy greens, and other vegetables. Dairy was the second most frequent food source for infections, which is interesting considering the vast majority of milk, cheese, yogurts, and other products sold in the U.S. is, by law, pasteurized.

Meat and poultry were to blame for 22 percent of foodborne illnesses and may also be to blame for contaminating produce. Livestock waste harboring pathogens can seep into surface and groundwater on farms, affecting produce crops. For instance, the 2010 Salmonella outbreak in spinach was largely attributed to groundwater containing animal feces, and the harmful, irresponsible practices of industrial-scale factory farming.

Raw milk sales and distribution are legal in many U.S. states, and most proprietors are local farmers selling directly to consumers. Some states, like Massachusetts, are considering passing legislation making it easier for farmers to bring raw dairy products to the people who want it. Others, like Wisconsin, are prosecuting a farmer for supplying a private buying club with raw milk and other fresh produce.

I want the dairy we all consume to be safe and cultivated in the most natural, organic, sanitary environment possible. The same goes for meat and for fruits, vegetables, grains, and everything else we consume to nourish our bodies. The debate over raw versus pasteurized milk is as much about food safety as anything else. Whether you choose to consume raw dairy or not, make sure the source of that dairy is pure.

Know where your food comes from so you can protect your family from disease and discourage farmers from the inhumane, unhealthy growing practices that have the potential to make us all sick in the long run.

by guest blogger Dierdre Imus, author and environmental health advocate



5 Food Myths Debunked

What Saved This Conventional Farm?

This Just In: Obesity Is a Disease


Tapan Mohanta
Tapan Mohanta4 years ago

most preferred one in India is raw version, pasteurized packed one for those who have no time to check their own food.

Rehana VN
Rehana VN4 years ago

I know lots of people that drink raw milk , no one's dropped dead yet. I think maybe impurities when milking might be the culprit so that could be a problem, however ,if done under sterile,clean conditions shouldnt be a problem.Perhaps the dairy industry with over pasteurization together with other nonsense that raises their prices will not favour getting it straight fom Daisy!

Lyn G.
Lyn Greenwood4 years ago

I was raised on raw milk, and I do not enjoy the reconstituted liquid apology now sold as milk in the supermarkets. It has not only been pasteurised and analysed to the nth degree, but has a faintly bluish tinge which no self respecting cow would acknowledge as hers!! Herds are well tested on a regular basis for disease, and as milking is now done by machinery which is well maintained, so the risk of 'catching' anything nasty is lower than the risk of eating a salad!

Genoveva M.
Genoveva M M4 years ago

Oh well.

Elena T.
Elena Poensgen4 years ago

Thank you :)

Anne G.
Anne G4 years ago

I just read a book where they wrote about how many people, especially children, died or contracted TB from drinking raw milk, or milk from cows who were carriers of the disease. I know a lot of people here on this site are against vaccines, but read a little history. It'll scare the doubt out of you.

Philipa Longley
Philipa Longley4 years ago

Thank you for sharing.

Erin Elizabeth
Erin Elizabeth4 years ago

Wow, I used to like care2 (and don't even drink dairy) but saying that pasteurized cook milk is 'safe' and the farmers who sell raw milk are bad and how bad raw milk is for you? very sad. they got it backward. IF i drank dairy (I used to- i do not now) i would never drink cook destroyed milk. That's the dangerous stuff.

Anne K.
Anne K.4 years ago

Delaware recently attempted to get a bill passed so that farmers could sell raw milk, but unfortunately it did not garner enough support. The Farm Bureau was against passing the bill - makes you wonder...

Sandi C.
Sandi C4 years ago