Is Crate Training Cruel? Here’s What Some Experts Have to Say

One of my dog walking clients recently adopted a 3-year-old Italian greyhound who wasn’t housebroken. He peed and pooped all over her house, and the rescue group where she adopted him suggested that she use crate training to housebreak her newest family member. Because my client works full time she called me in to walk the greyhound during the day. We had fun on our long walks and he willingly returned to his crate with a favorite treat and toy to settle down and relax until his “mom” returned home.

Everything was going according to plan except for one problem—my client wasn’t happy. Crating filled her with guilt as she thought it would traumatize her dog.

So, is crating cruel or is it an effective training tool?

The use of a crate as a training tool is controversial. Many leading animal welfare groups such as the HSUS and the ASPCA believe that when used properly crating is an effective and humane training tool. Behavioral experts at the HSUS recommend crating dogs until they can be trusted not to destroy the house, and after that leaving the crates around as a place where dogs can go voluntarily. Other groups such as PETA believe that crating is cruel and has become a popular “convenience practice” that is often used on adult dogs.

Crate training is essential for dogs at Best Friends Animal Society  

Teaching dogs to feel comfortable in crates is an essential part of the training at Best Friends Animal Society headquartered in Utah. Crating keeps the dogs safe as they settle into their foster homes and are transported by car or plane to their new homes. Learning to be comfortable in a crate also prepares them for possible emergency evacuations that would require transporting a large number of dogs to safety.

According to Best Friends, dogs are hardwired by their genetic history to be den animals. A den is a small, safe, well-defined space, a place where dogs instinctively feel safe. It is also a place that they instinctively avoid soiling and the combination of the two native traits are what makes crate training, done in the right way, a kind and effective component in house-training a new puppy or dog.

Best Friends Behavior Consultant Marcia Helm has successfully used crate training for the 250 foster dogs that have lived in her home. The crates, she said, protected the dogs and her home.

“Our objective is to make the crate a good happy safe place for dogs and if it’s introduced properly and utilized that way I find it a wonderful training tool,” Helm said. “Once I know the dogs are safe in the house I do let them roam freely, but I still leave the crates around so the dogs can use them if they want to.”

GERMAN SHEPHERD Dog                                                                    

The behaviorist cautions that the crate should never be used as a form of punishment and is also not a good training tool for dogs suffering from separation anxiety.

“Separation anxiety dogs don’t do well being confined. They will do almost anything to break out of the crate and can injure themselves,” Helm said. “In these cases, owners need to seek the help of a veterinarian or a behavior specialist.”

On the other hand, she finds that crates are extremely helpful when working with fearful dogs who appreciate the opportunity to retreat to the safety of the crate. Crating also helps exuberant dogs by providing them with a place to calm down and relax. In families with young children, a crate can be a wonderful refuge for dogs who need some quiet time. In this case, it’s essential that children are taught the dog is off limits when he is in his crate, Helm said.

For dog owners who are frustrated with home destruction but aren’t comfortable with crating as a training tool, Helm suggests cordoning off a small space and laying down puppy pads. She still advises leaving an open crate in the space so the dog can go there to relax. When a smaller space in the home isn’t an option, she suggests attaching an x-pen to the crate.

“As a trainer and a behaviorist my goal is to find what works best for the dog and the owner,” Helm said. “That sometimes means thinking outside the box.”

A crate is not a magical solution to common canine behavior. If not used correctly, a dog can feel trapped and frustrated. Following are some tips from the HSUS:

    • Don’t leave your dog in the crate too long. A dog that’s crated all day and night doesn’t get enough exercise or human interaction and can become depressed or anxious. You may have to change your schedule, hire a pet sitter or take your dog to a daycare facility to reduce the amount of time they spend in their crate each day.
    • Puppies under 6 months of age shouldn’t stay in a crate for more than three or four hours at a time. They can’t control their bladders and bowels for that long. The same goes for adult dogs being housetrained. Physically, an older dog can hold it, but they don’t know they’re supposed to.
    • The crate should be large enough for dogs to stand up and turn around in. If your dog is still growing, choose a crate size that will accommodate their adult size. Block off the excess crate space so your dog can’t eliminate at one end and retreat to the other.

More information on crate training can be found at Crate Training 101 and Crate Training: the Benefits for You and Your Dog

Photo Credit: Thinkstock

112 comments

Ingrid A
Past Member 2 months ago

thank you

SEND
Tatiana O
Tatiana O9 months ago

1) dogs are NOT “den animals”. Wild dogs don’t live in dens
2) dogs don’t love their crates. If they would, they wouldn’t cry when you try to “crate train” them
3) dogs need to move, stretch, run for healthy development. They can’t be confined for hours at a time
4) Most dogs, when released from the crate, run around the houses like crazy (which is also a simple behavioral sign that they have been distressed and needed movement)
5) dogs experience distress if they have to sit in their own urine or poop, and since little puppies don’t have full control of their excretion functions, these accidents will happen, which will also cause a serious distress
6) there are many countries around the world where practices of crate training for house pets just don’t exist - dogs there are totally fine. Moreover, on average they have less anxiety issues (unclear if it’s related to crates though or multiple other potential factors, but could be). In any case, it just proves that cages are not necessary for training or enjoyable cohabitation with dogs
7) the fact that over the time dogs stop crying in crates and even stay quiet when the owner is not home (more so than when they are allowed to stay outside the crate) doesn’t prove that they like it. It i

SEND
Leanne K
Leanne K12 months ago

I think it’s a sign you do not have control over your dog, nor do you have the time or the patience.
Yes, they will apparently be ok at the vet or shelter, supposedly but I’m not at all convinced
Your dog is a possession who can’t be a bother,
I would prefer you didnt have an animal, frankly

SEND
Cindy S
Past Member 12 months ago

if a dog like it it is ok. not all dogs like it. I had I dog years ago and he didn't have one. I never even heard of crates years ago.

SEND
Chrissie R
Chrissie R12 months ago

ALL my dogs have always loved their crates and I've crate-trained all my dogs including my current two.
No, it's not cruel...when done properly...not by some idiot who just wants the dog out of the way and gives everyone else a bad name.

SEND
Carole R
Carole Rabout a year ago

I have a couple friends who use a crate for their dogs. The dogs look at the crate as their bedroom. They go there on their own when they want some quiet time.

SEND
Vincent T
Past Member about a year ago

Thanks for this

SEND
Clare O'Beara
Clare Oabout a year ago

we sometimes confine one cat in a room away from us if she had bullied another cat. they do not like this although there is food water and a tray.

SEND
Clare O'Beara
Clare Oabout a year ago

make sure the pup has been out

SEND
Clare O'Beara
Clare Oabout a year ago

but not for too long

SEND