What is the Healthiest Milk Alternative?

A glass of milk for strong bones. Milk with cookies or morning cereal. Everyone loves milk, right? Not quite. Animal-derived milk does have its downside. These include allergies and lactose intolerance, possibly even the risk of certain cancers and diabetes. The good news is that those who want or need to stay away from cowís milk can do so with a number of non-dairy milk alternatives. These vary in their levels of nutrition, color, flavor and texture.

Soy Milk

A popular alternative to dairy milk, soy milk is a bean extract of soybeans and commonly sold in sweetened, unsweetened and flavored varieties, including chocolate and vanilla.

Pros: In many ways, soy milk is nutritionally equivalent to cowís milk. Itís often fortified with calcium, vitamins A and D and riboflavin, and it usually includes 8 to 10 grams of protein per serving. Soy milk can also contain isoflavones, which have been associated with a reduced risk of heart disease.

Cons: Even a little soy milk can cause severe allergic reactions to those with a soy allergy. In addition, a review published in 2014 in Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine revealed that soy might negatively impact fertility in men.

Almond Milk

Made from ground almonds, water and (in most cases) sweetener, almond milk is sweet with a creamy texture similar to dairy milk.

Pros: Almond milk contains lots of vitamin Eóabout 50% of the daily value in one cup. Weight watchers will like the fact that almond milk has 1/3 of the calories of 2% cow’s milk.

Cons: Almond milk has far less protein than dairy milk or soy milk. It also doesnít have the vitamins, minerals and fatty acids found in dairy milk, so itís important to look for fortified almond milk.

Rice Milk

Made from boiled rice, brown rice syrup and brown rice starch, rice milk is a popular alternative for cowís milk.

Pros: Rice milk is the most hypoallergenic of the milk alternatives. Itís free of soy, gluten and nuts, important for those who are allergic or canít tolerate these ingredients.

Cons: If youíre watching your weight, rice milk is high in carbohydrates. And itís low in protein and calcium compared to dairy milk. This milk is also thin and watery, so itís not a good cowís milk substitute for cooking or baking.

Coconut Milk

A close alternative to cowís milk, coconut milk most resembles the texture of whole dairy milk. Itís somewhat high in fat (about 5 grams of saturated fat per cup).

Pros: Its nutty flavor makes coconut milk suitable for many types of baked foods. Itís soy- and gluten-free, so those with multiple food allergies can tolerate this substitute. Coconut milk has far more potassium per cup than dairy milk (630 mg per cup, vs. 150 mg).

Cons: Coconut milk lacks the nutritional value of dairy milk. One cup of coconut milk contains 80 calories, 1 g of protein and 100 mg of calciumócompared to 100 calories, 8 g of protein and 300 mg of calcium for 1% dairy milk.

Flax Milk

A little thin and sweet, most flax milk is produced by organic, ethically responsible companies that use non-GMO flax.

Pros: High in fiber, flax milk is rich in alpha linoleic acids, which has been used to prevent and treat diseases of the heart and blood vessels. It is used to prevent heart attacks, lower high blood pressure, lower cholesterol, and reverse hardening of the blood vessels. When fortified, this non-dairy alternative has as much calcium as regular milk, so itís good for those who need healthy, adequate levels of calcium.

Cons: Flax milk is low in protein. Flavored varieties tend to be heavily sweetened, so read the label for sugar content.

Hemp Milk

No, you wonít get high on hemp milk. Made from hulled hemp seeds, water and (in most cases) sweeteners, hemp milk is a good alternative for those allergic to soy, nuts and gluten.

Pros: Hemp milk provides more iron than cowís milk. Itís also very high in omega-3 fatty acids, which have been shown to promote heart and brain health.

Cons: Unless fortified, hemp milk is relatively low in calcium. Itís rather expensive and can have a beany-nutty flavor that may not suit some taste buds. Many store bought varieties have sugar added, so read the label.

Milk Alternatives: 9 Recipes†


Brad H
Brad Habout a year ago


Maria R
Past Member about a year ago

thank you

Sue H
Sue Habout a year ago

Good to know, thanks.

Jan S
Past Member about a year ago

Thank you

Paola S
Past Member about a year ago

thanks for sharing

Carl R
Carl R1 years ago


Gerald L
Gerald L1 years ago

Today's news; Does drinking cow's milk help children grow taller?
Nutrition team finds 3-year-olds consuming alternative milks were 1.5 cm shorter on average
By Amina Zafar, CBC News Posted: Jun 07, 2017 4:44 PM ET Last Updated: Jun 07, 2017 4:44 PM ET; http://www.cbc.ca/news/health/milk-children-height-1.4149832

Everest Frenke, 2, drinks some fortified soy milk. The Toronto toddler's mother sometimes adds flax oil, peanut butter or hemp seeds to ensure her daughter is getting important nutrients. (CBC)

Related Stories
• Do we have it backward on giving kids low fat milk instead of whole?
• How to give babies peanut-based foods to cut allergy risk
• Preschoolers need just 2 cups of milk a day: MD
• Got milk? Not anymore, say Yukon goat dairy farmers
External Links
• American Journal of Clinical Nutrition
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external links.)
Like most parents, Andrea Thompson works hard to make sure her toddler eats nutritious foods.
The Toronto mother has been a vegan for four years and thinks carefully about the food she gives her two-year-old daughter, Everest Frenke. Sometimes she adds flax oil, peanut butter or hemp seeds to soy milk to ensure her daughter is getting important nutrie

Gerald L
Gerald L1 years ago

It is wrong to call all these alternatives [ milk ], the proper name would be [ water hydrated drinks ].

Baby Lucas was fed a diet of quinoa milk. Within 7 months he was dead.

Jetana A
Jetana A1 years ago

Good to see a comparison. But of course, a lot of us will still choose by taste!

Julie P
Julie Pham1 years ago