Why Should You Knit a Scarf?

I’ve started knitting again after a year-long break. I bought some beautiful hand-dyed, locally spun yarn in a brilliant mottled fuchsia, and then I got to work, knitting furiously for two days straight until I realized that my new infinity scarf was disproportionately huge. I had to undo everything and start over, my enthusiasm somewhat dampened.

When I took my knitting to a friend’s house, someone asked an interesting question: “Why would you bother knitting a scarf? It’s so much work and you can buy a great scarf for cheap anywhere.” It’s a good question. If it’s easy to buy a decent scarf for $10 at H&M, why would I spend $50 on handspun yarn and another week of knitting in order to get a finished product? It’s hardly economical.

But there’s more to it than that. The act of knitting is a strange combination of relaxation and activism, of protest and tradition. My urge to pick it up again started last month after reading Overdressed: The Shockingly High Cost of Cheap Fashion by Elizabeth Cline. (You can read my review here.) The author pushes for a “slow clothes” movement, the fashion equivalent of “slow food,” in which consumers start paying attention to the background of their clothes and what has gone into their production. Knitting is my small contribution to the slow clothes movement for the following reasons:

I’m creating a product of high quality. Because I’ve invested money and time into this scarf, it is far more valuable than anything I could buy for $10. I will care for it and it will last for many years, keeping its shape and colour long after cheaper scarves have fallen apart. Clothing is devalued in North America to the point where it’s practically disposable. It would be far better for the Earth if we stopped buying cheap items that don’t last and invested in fewer, higher quality items that do last.

Knitting is a way to reclaim independence. We live in a world where we depend on certain individuals and companies to perform highly specialized tasks for us. There’s something satisfying about taking on some of the responsibility for clothing production and sending a message to the industry that I don’t need them to make my scarves.

Knitting can help a local industry. It wasn’t cheap to buy two skeins of that locally produced yarn, but at least I’m making a statement with my consumer dollars to a nearby farmer, endorsing his or her decision to make a living raising sheep. According to Cline, if every American redirected 1 percent of their disposable income to domestically-made products, it would create 200,000 jobs. Cheap imported clothes become a lot more expensive when you calculate the loss of domestic jobs.

Finally, it feels really good to make something by hand. There’s something very peaceful about performing a simple, repetitive act with my fingers that results in useful yet beautiful things.

Do you knit or have another ‘slow clothes’-related hobby?

Simple Sewing Tips to Repair Clothes
25 Ways to Upcycle Old T-Shirts
5 Mason Jar Craft Projects

article by Katherine Martinko


Bea W.
Bea Wilson3 years ago

Interestingly, I can relate with Kara, but for me it's crochet. Over the years I have seen all kinds of expressions on peoples faces and have heard wonderful compliments about the things I have made. It's wonderful. People don't seem to be interested in learning these crafts. Learning to knit is my next craft. It'll be fun I think?

Tania S.
Tania S4 years ago

Thanks for the information.

Kat a.
Kathy L4 years ago

I've been a knitter for a little over 30 years. Knitting is good therapy for inner peace.

Carol P.
Carol P4 years ago

Love the sentiment in this post about using your purchasing dollars wisely rather than forking them over to big business.

Myriam G.
Myriam G4 years ago

I've always been a die-hard knitter, but this article made me a slow-clothes enthusiast! I'll learn more about the movement!

Linda Stuckey
Linda Stuckey4 years ago

Knitting is a form of meditation and a constructive use of leisure time. It keeps me sane and gives me a form of creative expression.

Franck R.
Past Member 4 years ago


Laura Saxon
.4 years ago

I don't knit, but thanks for sharing.

Sharon Davidson
Sharon Davidson4 years ago

I attend a knitting class at my church it is very rewarding and some of the ladies crochet as I do and we get to see the progress weekly of what we have accomplished and who we are going to give our gift to.It is very relaxing after a long days work to come home and relax with making something special,I enjoy it very much.

Natasha Salgado
Past Member 4 years ago

Well I guess i'll be needing knitting classes! Valid points made-thanks